News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jonas21 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:44AM (#21670729)
This is part of Schwab's merger with TD Ameritrade. Relevant bits from Schwab's FAQ [1]:

Q: Where will the combined company be headquartered?

A: As part of the integration process, the corporate headquarters of the combined companies will eventually relocate to Schwab’s new campus in Westlake, Texas. Both companies have a sizable presence in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. This will allow the firm to take advantage of the central location of Schwab’s new campus as the hub of a network of Schwab branches and operations centers that span the entire U.S., and beyond.

Q: What does the headquarters move mean for the future of Schwab’s presence in San Francisco?

A: Schwab was founded in San Francisco and has maintained a longstanding commitment to the Bay Area, which will continue. A small percentage of roles may move to Westlake over time, either through relocation or attrition. The vast majority of San Francisco-based roles, however, are not anticipated to be impacted by this decision. Schwab expects to continue hiring in San Francisco and retain a sizable corporate footprint in the city. Any additional real estate decisions will be made as part of the integration process, over time.

[1] https://www.aboutschwab.com/announcement

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by hkmurakami on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:00PM (#21670864)
TD Ameritrade is headquartered in Omaha. The HQ location choice is not driven by existing Ameritrafe footprint, or by the merger itself. The FAQ is simply addressing what will be, not starting that there was a cause and effect because of the proposed merger. Also, Schwab was already reducing SF headcount for years.

Also, afaik the merger is still in the prices of regulatory review.

All this being said, the merger likely gives a tactical opportunity to move HQ out of state without triggering a governmental review of some kind by pairing it with the merger event.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by rsj_hn on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:27PM (#21671387)
There is nothing wrong with moving to a better tax jurisdiction because you want lower taxes. It is perfectly legal, happens all the time, and is not something subject to a 'government review', because firms are expected to optimize their behavior in order to avoid taxes as much as possible, and even legally required to do so if they are to meet their obligations to maximize shareholder value. The whole idea that people change their behavior to avoid taxes is the basis of sin taxes - this is how things are supposed to work.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by wutbrodo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:42PM (#21671477)
> and even legally required to do so if they are to meet their obligations to maximize shareholder value.

This is a solid comment overall, but I really wish this particular widespread canard would die already. It's flatly untrue, the kind of myth that lives on because there are so many people who aren't capable of processing the benefits and costs of corporations and treat them as one-dimensional boogeymen out of a children's bedtime story.

(to be clear, that doesn't appear to be the case for you).

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by rsj_hn on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:27PM (#21673848)
It is not a canard. The purpose of a corporation is going to be specified in the corporate charter, and while some corporations are non-profits or have explicit charitable requirements, most have a charter that focuses on maximizing shareholder earnings. Almost no company has a charter that focuses on maximizing taxes paid.

That charter is a binding contract that governs the behavior of the officers of the company and shareholders, when they buy shares of a company, do so with their rights and the obligations of officers encoded in that charter. They are not buying blind -- they are buying into that charter. That is a contract that they expect to be followed.

The idea that a corporation can do whatever it wants and ignore shareholders is a fashionable myth in some lefty circles and has absolutely no basis in reality or corporate law. If you want to found a corporation whose charter is to help the poor, or to provide high paying secure jobs to workers, you can certainly do that, but then it goes in the charter and if a corporate officer were to start turning the company into a for profit venture she could get sued by the shareholders just as an officer turning a for profit company into a non-profit can get sued.

In addition to the legal obligation of abiding by the charter (in the sense that it is a contract and you can get sued for breaching it), most corporate charters are structured in such a way as to allow shareholders certain operational control: to replace board members who they don't believe are acting in their (the shareholder) interest, require shareholder approval for major things like executive pay, issuance of corporate debt, issuance of more stock, etc. This is another way that corporate officers are bound to serve shareholder interests and again these rights are all promised to the shareholder in the charter before they purchase stock, so that a shareholder knows what they are buying and what rights they have.

In addition to the daily operational controls that shareholders exercise, the charter also specifies what is necessary to change it -- usually a shareholder majority of some kind. This means if you displease the shareholders, they will sell your stock, lowering your stock price, allowing a hostile shareholder to buy up the company and throw management out and also rewrite the charter. Maybe even take the company private so they become the sole owner of the entire company. All of that is hanging, like a Damocles sword, over management, forcing management to cater to shareholder preferences.

If you don't like the current shareholder focus -- and there is a case to be made that we are too focused on the shareholder -- then you can go company by company and propose a vote to amend the current charter, assuming you can get the shareholders to agree -- but what you can't do is pretend that the vast majority of corporate charters aren't structured in such a way as to force corporate officers to maximize shareholder value. They are.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by comex on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:41AM (#21674055)
You moved the goalposts. Corporate officers may indeed be motivated to maximize profits by the threat of being thrown out by shareholders. But they are not legally required to do so, or at least they have no meaningful risk of losing a lawsuit over it; the business judgment rule creates a presumption that they are acting in the corporation’s best interests, a presumption which is hard to overcome. The main exception is if they sacrifice the corporation’s interests for personal financial gain (self-dealing), but that’s not what’s being discussed here.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by rsj_hn on Sunday December 01, 2019 @07:11AM (#21675110)
As I pointed out, if they violate the charter, which explicitly says that shareholder returns is the purpose of the corporation, then they are liable to be sued by either shareholders or state’s attorneys. That charter is a legally binding obligation. The requirement to disburse profits, have shareholders approve executive pay, etc which is also in the charter also becomes a legal obligation. It’s not a question of preferences but rather contracts that are heavily regulated.

https://smallbusiness.chron.com/consequences-violating-corpo...

“ State laws require the board of directors to act in the best interest of the corporation and its shareholders. Part of that responsibility is managing the affairs of the business according to certain legal standards. Once a director takes a seat on the board, he has various duties as the representative of the shareholders that the law places upon him, such as the duty of care and loyalty, that determine if he's doing his job properly. Even if your small corporation has few shareholders and all of them also sit on the board of directors, the shareholders in their capacity as directors must take action and make decisions that comply with the law and the corporation's governing documents, including the bylaws.”

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by trepanne on Sunday December 01, 2019 @07:31AM (#21675169)
Corporate charters don't generally include clauses requiring that profits be maximized, profits be disbursed, and executive pay be approved by shareholders.

Rather they tend to include maximally expansive language such as "all business activities legal in the state of XXX". It's a placeholder, delegating responsibility to the directors to the greatest extent permitted by law. This is the standard, for good reason.

Are the charitable donations of the Fortune 500 evidence of widespread violation of fiduciary duties?

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by rsj_hn on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:31AM (#21682125)
> Corporate charters don't generally include clauses requiring that profits be maximized, profits be disbursed, and executive pay be approved by shareholders.

This is false.

Corporate law requires that Board members faithfully represent the interest of stakeholders, and the corporate bylaws define who those stakeholders are. Generally they will he creditors, holders of preferred shares followed by holders of common shares. By defining the stakeholders, the corporate charter is defining who owns what and whose interest the board must represent. This is where all the activists who insist that corporations have stakeholders like "the environment" hit a road block -- they aren't going to get shareholder approval to list the environment as a stakeholder.

Corporate bylaws, which must be voted on and approved by shareholders, do spell out voting rights for shareholders, approval of executive pay, approval of debt issuance. This is very common.

People misunderstand how heavily regulated corporations are, because it is a funny ownership structure, where the owners -- the shareholders -- are distributed and don't actually run the company. This creates all sorts of principle agent problems and thus corporate law grants shareholders many rights and imposes many obligations on corporations. Shareholders can audit the books. Shareholders can sue. All the ways that the business does anything from make a decision to issue debt must be spelled out in bylaws that shareholders must approve. Corporations must have a board. The board must be elected by the shareholders. The board has to act in their interest. The board gets to appoint the CEO, etc.

State law also defines the liability shield, that as long as board members are acting faithfully in the interests of shareholders, they can't be sued, but as soon as they are not they can be.

Things like corporate donations are generally justified as helping the bottom line by improving the brand. But you do need to show how they are helping shareholders, otherwise it would be a breach of fiduciary duty and the liability shield would be lost at which point shareholders could sue.

But even apart from this, when the shareholders turn against you they can sell, and if someone buys a majority of the shares the company becomes theirs, they own it, they can take it private, they can throw out management, etc. This ensures that the board be focused on keeping shareholders happy above all other concerns.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by wutbrodo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:38PM (#21676648)
You're changing the subject to substantially narrower claims, none of which I disagree with. The claim wasn't that corporations aren't free to explicitly optimize for goals other than or contrary to shareholder value (this seems trivially true AFAIK). It was that corporations are forced by law to take specific steps like "doing everything they can to optimize tax avoidance", and are legally prohibited from leaving any optimization opportunity on the table (as long as it's legal). Corporations are afforded far more discretion in this area, legally speaking, than your OP comment states.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by rsj_hn on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @06:42AM (#21691581)
I never said that they couldn't do it. But I said that these tradeoffs were governed by the corporate charter, which itself needed shareholder approval to change.

Thus shareholders can agree to bring in other stakeholders. They can agree that a certain business should maximize its taxes. They can agree to turn the company into a non-profit. But they have to be the ones to agree to do it, and it needs to be spelled out in the various bylaws that define who the stakeholders are that the Board members must faithfully represent.

It is not up to management. It is not up to employees. Only the shareholders decide this. The broader claims come from the assumption that shareholders generally support their own economic interests exclusively. My own observation of the world is that this is the case. Even if a shareholder cares about the poor, they would rather have the maximum return from their assets and then donate some money to the poor themselves, rather than asking their investments to donate to the poor and lower their return.

So the technicalities are that yes, shareholders can give up these claims if they want to. Admitting this is not, IMO, backing off from my broader claim, but recognizing that shareholder supremacy also empowers shareholders to direct a corporation to include other factors than profits.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by FussyZeus on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:17PM (#21672189)
> The whole idea that people change their behavior to avoid taxes is the basis of sin taxes - this is how things are supposed to work.

What sin taxes are at play here?

Edit: Or just downvote I guess, it was just a question.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jbc1 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:52PM (#21673282)
No sin taxes are at play here. Their reference to sin taxes was to show that tax minimisation is expected behaviour.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by tootie on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:35PM (#21671428)
Ameritrade has always been based in Omaha, but the T in TD stands for Toronto. So headquarters locations is a pretty malleable designation.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by scurvy on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:37PM (#21672014)
Yep, and after this the new company will have nothing to do with Canada. Toronto Dominion shares in TD Ameritrade will be cashed out. Though it will be interesting to see if they still get their back end cut like they do now.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by hkmurakami on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:25PM (#21672488)
TD Ameritrade is a subsidiary of TD Bank. Subsidiaries have separate HQs from their owners. See BRKA for other examples.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by cortesoft on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:21PM (#21670987)
Why would the government review a headquarters move?
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by hailwren on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:28PM (#21671030)
States and cities often give large corporations preferential treatment to maintain a footprint there. I'm not sure if this is the case for Schwab/SF, but if they are getting a break then announcing a move might be a time for SF/California to start clawing back benefits.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jdavis703 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:41PM (#21671111)
It sounds like they'll be keeping a sizable amount of staff in SF still. SF has a gross receipts tax on certain companies with HQ's in the city. As such auditors will want to ensure this isn't just a tax avoidance gimmick. By pairing this move with an acquisition Charles Schwab has a stronger defense against such an accusation.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by throwGuardian on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:52PM (#21671189)
Tax avoidance "scam". Moving to Texas to reduce taxes, especially SF taxes which are basically useless to the payer [1], [2] is a "scam"? What's the legal framework preventing moves out of SF? Is it indentured slavery to the city council if you ever open an office in SF?

[1]: https://www.newsweek.com/san-francisco-district-attorney-pub...

[2]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2019/04/15/map...

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jdavis703 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:01PM (#21671248)
The problem is perception. If a company seems to only move their headquarters in name only (IOW most of the staff still stays in SF), then that seems sketchy. If they make a clean separation and shutdown their SF presence, that doesn't appear as dodgy.

And these companies are not just moving to Texas. I live in Oakland, CA and many of these companies are relocating here. I don't care if they leave SF, but if they're cheating on their taxes, that's just not right.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by throwGuardian on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:08PM (#21671290)
How are they "cheating"? It appears like the city is the one cheating, refusing to enforce criminal law, which taxes are paying for. The city is cheating so much that they make some of the highest per capita tax revenue disappear without providing commensurate services

Maybe you can mention the statute relevant to HQs? I'm not aware of any

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jdavis703 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:46PM (#21671499)
This was one of the most contentious ballot initiatives for 2018. The text called headquarters "adminstrative offices" FWIW: https://ballotpedia.org/San_Francisco,_California,_Propositi...

This measure was pretty well known. It was one of the most controversial local measures in 2018 (even gaining substantial regional coverage: I'm in Oakland not SF and heard a lot about it).

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by philwelch on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:38PM (#21672283)
I see this (like a lot of things) as a negotiation tactic:

1. SF levies taxes on companies headquartered in SF. The message: “Pay us for the privilege of being in SF”.

2. SF companies move their headquarters but promise not to cut jobs in SF. The message: “We already provide lots of middle-class jobs in your city, providing tax revenues. It is not in your interest for those jobs to go away.”

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by garmaine on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:16PM (#21671327)
No one cares. Have you ever made a decision as a customer based on the company’s tax resident status?
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jdavis703 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @01:32PM (#21676972)
It's not the only decision point, but I try to avoid companies that exhibit a pattern of scummy behavior such as Wal-Mart, Nestle or Uber. Further I'm not only a consumer. I'm also a potential (small time) investor and employee of these companies. The bar for acceptable behavior is even higher if I'm going to work or invest with them.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by blackflame on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:45PM (#21671135)
When will the people of SF learn you cannot tax yourself to prosperity
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by jdavis703 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:15PM (#21671655)
The City & County of SF has the seventh highest median income of all U.S. counties [0]. The GDP of the Bay Area ranks ahead of all but 16 countries [1]. If taxes are correlated with prosperity it'd seem as though SF had found a way to tax itself to prosperity. (Of course in reality economics and tax policy are far more complicated than this).

0: https://bea.gov/newsreleases/regional/lapi/lapi_newsrelease.... 1: https://web.archive.org/web/20171208145551/https://www.bea.g...

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by Nuzzerino on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:08PM (#21672152)
Your argument assumes the correlation, but you're arguing that the causation exists without even establishing the correlation.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by blackflame on Thursday December 12, 2019 @02:06AM (#21769877)
You can’t ride on the coattails of FANGO (Oracle) forever. For every person doing well you have just as many doing drugs in a tent on the streets below multimillion dollar 2 bedroom lofts
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by godzillabrennus on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:00PM (#21671235)
When they move to Texas.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by cjsplat on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:11PM (#21671633)
Where they will learn that Texas government pays for itself with oil and gas extraction taxes, which don't exist in California.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by _-david-_ on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:20PM (#21671677)
The Bay Area pays for itself with the tech industry.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by blackflame on Thursday December 12, 2019 @02:08AM (#21769888)
No, the Bay Area rides on the coattails of tech. Severs can be anywhere and the second they decide Nevada (Cough Oracle) is cheaper, good by to all the money financing the impractical public policy. Humans are naturally selfish and greedy. That is fundamentally incompatible with any socialization of sufficient size
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by scurvy on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:23PM (#21672477)
Texas and the oil industry are one and the same, fully intertwined. God help the poor soul that owns land where a private oil company wants to build a pipeline or plant. Said land will be instantly seized by the company under eminent domain laws and the owner will get a pittance in return.

If you're cool with that, then Texas is a great place for you to live.

While this article is about Louisiana, the same laws (and practices) exist in Texas: https://www.nola.com/news/environment/article_75b4ff32-0d87-...

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by Keverw on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:37AM (#21674359)
Yeah. Sadly you never really own your house. Even after you payoff the mortgage, which many won't because they always refinance and consolidate loans. But even if you do end up paying off the mortgage, then you have to pay rent to the government, which who knows when your neighborhood will be torn down to build a highway or high speed rail project.

Then if you own the land, you don't even own the water, oil or whatever else might be under it. Remember abou a decade ago seeing something where a guy was disputing the county in Oregon over water rights, and they even illegally entered his property with no warrants or anythings.

Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by mapgrep on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:44PM (#21672045)
It wouldn’t, OP said the government would review the _merger_ - federal antitrust review pretty standard in mergers this large.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by stjohnswarts on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:14PM (#21671652)
The companies may have contractual obligations to the city. So they'll check and see if the company is violating those.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by txcwpalpha on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:39PM (#21672024)
This move was almost certainly planned long before the merger. They announced construction of a massive, headquarters-sized campus in Westlake several years ago, and they're already almost done building 3 of the huge office buildings (with 2-3 more to come). My guess is that the move is an entirely separate decision but was combined with this announcement for convenience sake.
Re:Schwab Leaves San Francisco for Texas by viburnum on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:44PM (#21671130)
Companies locate their headquarters solely on where their CEO wants to live.