News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by anaganisk on Friday November 29, 2019 @10:59PM (#21668426)
If the code is stable, why does it require maintenance at all? I dont think the amount of commits in last 6 months should even be a metric. Issues would be a better place to look for maintenance.
Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by peterwwillis on Friday November 29, 2019 @11:50PM (#21668592)
There's no such thing as "permanently stable", just "it worked the way we expected at release time". As it keeps being used in different environments, with different inputs, different use cases, etc, suddenly it's not working the way someone originally expected, or it doesn't work with newer stuff. Then bugs happen, or it requires new ways to work with newer software. So code changing over time is a sign that it's actually being used and someone is continuing to make it work.

Example: Linux 2.0.39 [1] was released in January 2001, no code changes since then. Some might say it's really stable by now, right? But that doesn't make sense; how could it be more stable than when it was released in 2001? Actually, it's much less stable. Try to download it, compile it, and run it on your modern system today. Will it even compile? Is your hardware fully supported? Will any new software break running under that old of a kernel? Probably all these and more problems will happen; yet we call it "stable". If you want to actually use it today, you would need to maintain the code.

This is why most of the cost of software is in the maintenance. As long as you're running it, you're maintaining it. (The exception is mainframes running the same hardware & software forever)

[1] https://mirrors.edge.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/v2.0/linux-...

Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by doomrobo on Friday November 29, 2019 @11:15PM (#21668474)
There are multiple issues from over 5 months ago that have no response

https://github.com/keydotcat/keycatd/issues

Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by Hackbraten on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:45AM (#21669720)
And allegedly, security issues too, including possible SQL injection.

https://github.com/keydotcat/keycatd/issues/2

Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by nathancahill on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:18AM (#21669830)
Ouch
Re:Show HN: Keycat – A self-hosted end-to-end encrypted pass... by madamelic on Friday November 29, 2019 @11:35PM (#21668531)
>If the code is stable, why does it require maintenance at all?

That attitude is fine for left-pad, security-centric products, not so much, in my opinion.