News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great American Eye Exam Scam by eru on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @10:30PM (#21654393)
Yes, but if you insist, your mechanic will probably still do what you ask them, as long a you pay up.
Re:The Great American Eye Exam Scam by Scoundreller on Thursday November 28, 2019 @02:48AM (#21655389)
I’m 50/50 on this. The dealerships can be mindless flow-chart followers:

It’ll say “When A occurs, try replacing X” and they’ll do that, even though my notes stated that I switched all the Xs around and the problem didn’t move with them.

Re:The Great American Eye Exam Scam by eru on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:20AM (#21655528)
Yes. And sometimes I even want a service provider that insists they know better. (Eg I frequent some coffee shops like that.)

The crucial thing is that there are alternative providers where I can get exactly what I say I want, and get it.

Re:The Great American Eye Exam Scam by zrobotics on Thursday November 28, 2019 @11:05AM (#21658249)
As a former mechanic, at least my shop would occasionally refuse to let a vehicle leave the shop- the one example that I remember most clearly was a SUV that came in for an oil change. The owner was planning on a 800 mile trip with their family and wanted an oil change before leaving. One of the wheels had a serious suspension problem, and would likely fall off shortly & cause a rollover.

We weren't going to let that truck leave our shop w/o getting fixed, none of us wanted dead kids on our conscience. We extended credit to the customer & cut our rate so the owner could afford it. Point being, in this case we definitely knew better than the customer, somehow they didn't realize a wheel falling off at highway speed is dangerous. P

However, that was a very rare situation. If a customer insisted they wanted work done that we didn't feel was necessary, we would tell them so but still do the work if they wanted it.