Does this mean it would be ok to ban all evening news programs?
Nah, they were caught with their hand in the cookie jar.
For critical content outside China, they minimize it via censorship when possible. Once the public becomes aware of censorship, they stop censoring.
So in this case, there are probably still things being removed from TikTok that are critical of China, we just aren't aware of them because they aren't from this girl's account. As for this girl's account, they can probably artificially lower likes or something. The point of censorship is to do it without being caught.
Not in my experience. The usual cycle on Weibo is that some sensitive news breaks, e.g. by eyewitnesses posting videos. This gathers attention until related hashtags start trending, at which point the Weibo censors notice it and remove the trending hashtags. Afterwards, you can still use a direct search to find posts about the event, but only if you already know about it. If you repeat the search, you'll notice search results disappearing or having their pictures removed. Some time later, the first post for searches about e.g. the time and location of the event will return some official statement, with the comment section disabled. Some other search terms will still turn up posts from the first wave of activity, but after a day or so those disappear as well.
If the event is very sensitive, searches for it get blocked completely, even if awareness is high. For example, one study [0] found that among a sample of Beijing students who neither use VPN nor have a roommate who does, 56% answered a quiz on the Panama Papers correctly. If they had a VPN-using roommate, this increased to 78%. Nonetheless, when I search for "巴拿马文件" on Weibo, I get told there are no search results. [1]
[0] http://as.nyu.edu/content/dam/nyu-as/econ/documents/2018-fal...
[1] https://s.weibo.com/weibo/%25E5%25B7%25B4%25E6%258B%25BF%25E...
[0] http://pilerats.com/news/the-artist-who-gifted-us-that-nude-...
Meanwhile, Chinese tech companies are beholden to the whims of China's CCP leaders. China's internet is completely controlled by the CCP.
There is zero moral equivalence between the US Government and China.
How would we know that?
When ActivisionBlizzard, a US company, banned a player for trying to turn a private event into a political platform nobody wanted to see evidence for how "The CCP forced ActiBlizz to do that!", it was just accepted as established fact, even without the slightest bit of evidence for it.
> Criticism of the US, US politicians and Government officials is rampant on Western social media.
Just like a demand to moderate it even more [0]. Just like this kind of criticism can have very far-reaching consequences in the real world [1].
> The US Government doesn't try to censor this.
No, it just nudges US social media companies into doing it for them under the very real threat of having government regulation forced on them [2] As a German, I'm plenty familiar with this kind of "Not government-censorship censorship" that gives legal plausible deniability but still ends up forcing people into censoring their content if they want it to get any exposure.
> Meanwhile, Chinese tech companies are beholden to the whims of China's CCP leaders.
Unlike US companies? The third-party doctrine [3] is still a very real thing, heavy cooperation between US private companies and US intelligence services is still a very real thing . Just because people sometimes talk about PRISM, and pretty much only that [4], does not change the reality that these crimes are still going on to this day.
But that's okay because "We are allowed to talk about it!", somewhere besides the mainstream, every couple of months when Snowden manages to pierce a headline trough the attention glass ceiling, after that it's back to business as usual.
A reminder: Intel is subsidized by the US government, Intel's ME is pretty much exactly what Bloomsberg fictional Chinese super spy chip supposedly does [5]. The difference is: Intel ME is real [6], Bloomberg's chip has yet to be actually found, even tho there are supposedly tens of thousands of physical samples in the US.
This has very real consequences for companies outside the US [7]. Deflecting from that whole situation by going "We sometimes talk about PRISM", when nothing changes and no major political movements are pushing for change, is belittling the problem for the sake of projecting a completely fictional moral high ground.
[0] https://medium.com/@nayafia/why-do-millennials-support-gover...
[1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/08/27/border-deny-entry-united-s...
[2] https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/327887/pbs-th...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine
[4] http://www.europarl.europa.eu/document/activities/cont/20140...
[5] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-10-04/the-big-h...
[6] https://www.bsi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Warnmeldungen/DE/CB/2018/...
[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON#Examples_of_industrial...
Now, if someone in China would like to learn more about the massacre in Tiananmen Square, would they be easily able to visit (say) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protes... to read more about it?
No, not at all, and they absolutely do not.
> Who remembers PRISM? Did the government censor it? Or did we just conveniently forget?
I do, but sure, many don't. But that's mostly evidence that the market for grievances against the government is a competitive one, in the US (and the west in general) - you'll always be able to cherry pick some single issue (or several) that are serious, yet fall below the radar of the general populace.
In the west, we can curse our leader's names all day long, publicly with a megaphone. In the east, you can't mention Winnie the Pooh.
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...