Re:Visualizing Hip-Hop Melodies (2016)
by peteforde on Friday November 29, 2019 @10:25PM
(#21668330)
One of the most educational and interesting explainer videos I've ever seen is Vox's "Rapping, Deconstructed". Please consider this required watching, even if you have no interest in hip-hop music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QWveXdj6oZU
Re:Visualizing Hip-Hop Melodies (2016)
by pickdenis on Friday November 29, 2019 @10:05PM
(#21668265)
(This isn't related to hip-hop or melodies.)
I have absolute pitch; I can tell the pitch of any musical note I hear without any reference at all. I can also produce any pitch within my vocal or whistling range without a reference. This all comes completely naturally to me, and I don't have to think about it. Listening to this rap song, I noticed something strange.
The article talks about the melody of the song, but the rapper isn't singing. Of course, his rapping voice still has a pitch but it's actually not obvious to me what note he's "singing". If I listen very hard, I can still pick out the pitches of his notes (like how he centers on D). However, it is much much harder for me to tell the pitch of a speaking voice (or rapping voice) than a singing voice. This leads me to believe that there is a separate, functionally discrete part of my brain dedicated to processing music.
It also perhaps explains why I don't like rap music that much; it feels like my brain processes it as though it is spoken word rather than music, creating a somewhat strange and unmusical experience.
Re:Visualizing Hip-Hop Melodies (2016)
by paggle on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:14PM
(#21671927)
A lot of aspiring rappers don’t realize they are just singing with shorter vowels. If you don’t understand this you will rap in the key of 448 Hz over a beat in the key of 440 Hz and it will sound like dogshit.
Re:Visualizing Hip-Hop Melodies (2016)
by adamiscool8 on Friday November 29, 2019 @09:32PM
(#21668154)
This is really cool -- I know I tend to enjoy certain songs that share certain characteristic flows, this would be a fun way to sort of "quantify" and organize a music library. I wonder if Spotify uses a technique like this as a heuristic for their song suggestions.
After you watch that, I suspect you'll hear this Kendrick Lamar track with new ears: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZTYgq4EoRo
I know that while I am still very much a jazz/rock person, those videos expanded my perception of what was musically possible. No hyperbole on my end.
I have absolute pitch; I can tell the pitch of any musical note I hear without any reference at all. I can also produce any pitch within my vocal or whistling range without a reference. This all comes completely naturally to me, and I don't have to think about it. Listening to this rap song, I noticed something strange.
The article talks about the melody of the song, but the rapper isn't singing. Of course, his rapping voice still has a pitch but it's actually not obvious to me what note he's "singing". If I listen very hard, I can still pick out the pitches of his notes (like how he centers on D). However, it is much much harder for me to tell the pitch of a speaking voice (or rapping voice) than a singing voice. This leads me to believe that there is a separate, functionally discrete part of my brain dedicated to processing music.
It also perhaps explains why I don't like rap music that much; it feels like my brain processes it as though it is spoken word rather than music, creating a somewhat strange and unmusical experience.
Is there an open source alternative for Melodyne?