- where is the state kept, and
- where is the state mutated?
There is some state kept in objects like books and buildings and databases.
But the individual human brains are the greatness/shame of the nation.
There is a cognitive crutch "The American People" that is frequently leaned on, but the large the population symbolically aggregated for the assertion, the less meaningful it seems.
Hence my disagreement when someone says:
> I have very little doubt that countries are like their own people.
It gets really hard to make any point stick at scale.
Unless backed up with really good polling data, the phrase is total nonsense.
It's a flag indicating: "hogwash".
On the other hand, when politicians say "the people want it" it's almost always bs. What they mean is that, in the best case, they have a slight absolute majority- but often only a relative one. But that doesn't really count much- the issues they talk about are already within the frame of what is culturally possible in that country. Trump was elected with less than 50% of the votes, so he doesn't represent "the people"; however, he would have struggled to get 5% in Germany- so in some sense electing Trump does represent "the American people"- about as much as Hillary Clinton does.
When an emotional undercurrent or specific attitude is present in a population- be it the result of current events or of a longstanding cultural heritage, then it will reflect at state level. Thinking of interpreting history as the result of external conditions and the choices of few people in power is like trying to interpret the behaviour of a person as the combination of external events and individual neurons firing.