News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by rayiner on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:48PM (#21640664)
It only seems like a technicality if you don't know the tortured history of this case: https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art...

The "public's right of access" to the beach is not at issue in this case. (See pp. 429-430 of the above.) Private ownership of the land in question dates back to before California was a state. When the Mexican-American war ended, the United States entered into the Treat of Guadalupe-Hidalgo, which among other things promised the protection of private property rights that had been granted by the Spanish and Mexican governments in the land that was being ceded to the United States. The California Lands Act of 1851 set up proceedings wherein Mexican and Spanish land titles were turned into U.S. federal patents (land titles).

More than a century later, California added Article X, sec. 4 to its constitution, which declared a public easement over tidal lands to be held for the benefit of the public. In a series of cases, the Supreme Court held that the federal Treaty obligation to protect the scope of private property rights that had been granted by the Spanish and Mexican governments could not be impaired by California's later assertion of a sovereign right of the public to access tidal waters: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=122714134443780...

Because California had not asserted any public easement in the proceedings under the 1851 act, Khosla's beach is not subject to the general right of the public to access beaches. (See pp. 430 of the above.)

This whole litigation is therefore about a different issue entirely: the public dedication doctrine, which says that private land can become subject to a public easement if "dedicated" to public use. That's where the whole "private parking" thing comes in. Martin's beach was operated as a beach accessible to the public, but where a fee was charged for access. That doesn't count as dedication to the public.

So this case is really about two things that aren't technicalities at all: (1) the relatively small number of California property titles granted by the Mexican and Spanish governments are protected under Treaty against later State assertions of authority; and (2) the difference between dedicating private property to public use, and selling access to property to members of the public.

More generally, technicalities matter. Anglo legal systems like ours are not only about governing society, but protecting individuals and their property from the government. That's why the Magna Carta is a long list of things the King can't do, many of which are the foundation for our Bill of Rights. Protections of private property from seizure by the government for "public purposes" is right there in the Constitution, in the Takings Clause. The United States has thus been fastidious in protecting private property rights inherited from England, Spain, France, etc.

This is also about not changing the rules after the fact. There's lots of fair ways to structure a society. But it undermines notions of rule of law for the government to change the terms of the bargain after-the-fact. A state could be entirely justified in declaring that all oil fields in the state belongs to the state to lease for the benefit of the public. But the state should not be able to sell oil fields to private parties, and then come back later and declare that "in the public interest" the state should get half of all the oil production.

Many governmental abuses result from ignoring "technicalities" in favor of some vaguely-defined (and usually opportunistic) view of the "public's right[s]." The government gives out a property right, because it doesn't have the capital to develop the property itself, and then tries to get more than it bargained for once someone has taken the time to develop that property. One of the things that has made America so successful is that we don't do that. (And instances where we have done that, such as with treaty obligations to Native Americans, are rightfully a source of national shame.)

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by michaelt on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:03PM (#21640832)
> This is also about not changing the rules after the fact. There's lots of fair ways to structure a society. But it undermines notions of rule of law for the government to change the terms of the bargain after-the-fact.

Surely that happens all the time, though?

I mean, if I brought a car factory in 1950 is it unjust that the government changed the deal by forcing me to start supplying seatbelts in the 1960s?

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by rayiner on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:15PM (#21640981)
Oftentimes it's unavoidable. You operate businesses subject to the (legitimate) right of the government to create laws of general applicability. But there is a spectrum.

In this case, a California court of appeals found that there was no "public trust" right to access the beach years ago. So what did the state do? It pursued a frivolous theory based on the idea that just because someone has been operating a public beach, they and all their successors must keep operating a public beach. That's not a law of general application "requiring everyone to put seatbelts in cars." That's abuse targeting a single individual and his property.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by schoen on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:23PM (#21641669)
This reminds me of an old article by David D. Friedman, "Choosing Metarules for Legal Change".

http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Metarules/Metarules.h...

It discusses some of the problems with both horns of the dilemma about changing rules.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by beerandt on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:26PM (#21641704)
Also, treaties trump any state or other federal law.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by WWLink on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:16PM (#21641004)
Knowing HN, yeah, they probably consider seatbelts extreme big government overreach lol. "Let the market decide what safety devices people want! You're just raising costs for everyone with these unnecessary nannies!"
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by harryh on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:16PM (#21641002)
This is just me, a non lawyer, talking. But I kinda feel like the SCOTUS cases you reference were wrongly decided. When CA asserted its public easement over tidal lands it's hard for me to see why a taking from a regular piece of land should be any different than a piece of land that happened to be governed by the Mexican government over a century ago.

At some point doesn't the past have to become the past?

I think Khosla should be allowed to shut down the parking lot, but be required to maintain some sort of minimal road/path easement.

I should really read the full SCOTUS decision though before feeling confident in this POV.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by vageli on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:43PM (#21641288)
> This is just me, a non lawyer, talking. But I kinda feel like the SCOTUS cases you reference were wrongly decided. When CA asserted its public easement over tidal lands it's hard for me to see why a taking from a regular piece of land should be any different than a piece of land that happened to be governed by the Mexican government over a century ago.

Because part of the terms of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo were that Mexicans residing in land ceded to the US at the time would retain certain rights.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by 205guy on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:04PM (#21642111)
Is Khosla Mexican or descended from the Mexican landowners? Why were the special property rights of the Mexican landowners under the treaty passed to subsequent US owners of the land? So now there is land in CA that is not federal or native-American land, but it is not subject to CA laws. That's the part that doesn't seem logical in this.

Also maybe how CA could end this situation: pass a law that all current property rights are guaranteed, but only rights recognized under current CA law are conveyed at sale. Or maybe it needs to be a US law--or a treaty amendment with Mexico.

It's the least we could do for Khosla.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by beerandt on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:29PM (#21642357)
>pass a law that all current property rights are guaranteed, but only rights recognized under current CA law are conveyed at sale.

Part of a right of ownership is to be able sell or otherwise dispose of property (or the rights thereof).

Saying you can own it, but not sell it isn't ownership. At best, it's usufruct.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by ip26 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @08:23AM (#21647580)
In CA I can't sell my current property tax rate.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by vageli on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:59PM (#21642632)
> So now there is land in CA that is not federal or native-American land, but it is not subject to CA laws. That's the part that doesn't seem logical in this.

Just wanted to point out that this kind of arrangement exists already for things like embassies.

> Also maybe how CA could end this situation: pass a law that all current property rights are guaranteed, but only rights recognized under current CA law are conveyed at sale. Or maybe it needs to be a US law--or a treaty amendment with Mexico.

I don't sympathize with Khosla and admit that I haven't fully researched the impacts of the treaty but it does seem like something most easily resolved by the federal government.