News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:39AM (#21639880)
California's beach access law is fairly unique. Not some kind of universal human right. I'm not aware of it existing in any other jurisdiction.

Managing access to scarce resources is the primary purpose of the system of private property.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by draugadrotten on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:47AM (#21639970)
There are many jurisdictions with public beach access.

Spain - https://www.spanishpropertyinsight.com/legal/ley-de-costas-c... Sweden - https://visitsweden.com/about-the-right-of-public-access/ Australia - https://www.news.com.au/travel/travel-advice/travellers-stor...

and so on... all but a search query away.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:26PM (#21640414)
I'm from Sweden, and our rules seem quite a bit less permissive than California's.

You're allowed to move freely on most land, and even camp there. But that right ends when you're within sight of the owners home.

https://visitsweden.com/about-the-right-of-public-access/

California law has no such exceptions. You're allowed on the beach up to the high tide level, regardless of if somebody's home is right there.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by arcticbull on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:28PM (#21640437)
Which any soon to be property owner would know before buying a place. If the rules were a surprise to Mr Khosla he should be suing his realtor and not the state.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by jahaja on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:59PM (#21642062)
Well, as a fellow swede I can say that this is only half the story, because not only do we have the very extensive right to roam law, but we also have an additional law regarding this in particular called "Strandskydd" (literally beach protection) which makes it very hard and exceptional to make a coast line private.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by wolco on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:58PM (#21641426)
Seems like a loophole where anyone would build a house close to the water to prevent public access.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by simlevesque on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:58AM (#21640100)
France too IIRC.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by aboodman on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:20PM (#21642827)
Hawaii too.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by chongli on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:56AM (#21640070)
In Nordic (and other European) countries the access right is much broader, not restricted to beaches. It's called Freedom to Roam [1]. Exclusivity of private property is not an unambiguous universal.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam#Nordic_countri...

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:51PM (#21641365)
As a Swede living in California, I think I have some knowledge of this.

I don't think the Swedish "Allemansrätten" would allow the public to a beach in front of someone's home, as the California rule does, and as this fight is about.

I don't know how close this specific billionaire housing unit is to the beach, so I can't speak to this case, but the Swedish rule is less permissive than the California one.

I would also observe that these "right to roam" rules work well in sparsely populated places like Scandinavia, but you won't see much of them in more dense jurisdictions.

California is pretty much the size of Sweden, but with 4x the population.

https://visitsweden.com/about-the-right-of-public-access/

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by wolco on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:00PM (#21641454)
In Canada we don't have those rights. But we do have mineral rights in northern regions where anyone can stake a claim on private property for mineral rights. It's as simple as marking around the area.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by jahaja on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:13PM (#21642187)
What? The general rule in Sweden is that 100m from the coast line is protected.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by vidarh on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:15PM (#21640287)
In fact, I'd claim that there are almost no jurisdictions where there are no limitations on the control of private property.

Even if we limit it to "just" restrictions on public access, I don't think there are many jurisdictions that don't have carve-outs that provides protections for public access of some sort to some private land.

The reason, of course, being that most countries have traditions of access that long pre-dates modern property law, and that had to be accommodated.

In Norway, the freedom to roam was considered so intrinsic to Norwegian culture that is was not even mentioned in law until the 1960's, because it was considered "obvious", despite the fact that the Norwegian legal system is based on codified laws with very limited use of precedents, and certainly no "common law" element. In a completely opposite way of seeing it, Sweden embedded it in their constitution, because it was considered such an innate right.

While the expansive freedom to roam of the Nordic countries, is relatively rare, ensuring public access to the shore has been considered not just an issue of leisure access, but an issue of guaranteeing economic interests and food safety for centuries in a large proportion of countries with shore lines, and so has been very widespread - countries that don't guarantee access to the "dry" part of the beach have often still guaranteed access to the tidal zone, for example, to allow for fishing, or gathering mussels etc.

The idea that some people have of property rights as something exclusive just does not match reality - there's been a very acute recognition in most legal systems that property rights restricts the freedoms of the general public, and that as a consequence some trade-off must be made. The question is generally not if one needs to be made, but how extensive the right of public access should be.

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by peterwwillis on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:57PM (#21640760)
Hawaii's beaches are all open to the public. County governments and private developers are required to provide public access and parking in areas where the shoreline is dominated by residential dwellings.

> Managing access to scarce resources is the primary purpose of the system of private property.

The purpose of private property is economic. Locke's theory of private property was that because a laborer improves nature through their labor, they are thus entitled to the fruits of said labor, with the intention that they will keep up the land better than common land. In other words, they worked hard to develop their garden, so they get exclusive management of it. The result of this work on the land was intended to result in improved economic output.

But the quality of the land, or the result of the labor of its management, is a separate concern from access. We're talking about wanting the public to have access, not for it to be kept better, or to be used as an economic tool. According to (at least one) theory of private property, an individual owner could still maintain it properly while allowing public access to it. And that's probably why a UK law allows the public to roam on private property (well, that and traditional rights).

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:42PM (#21641281)
The public roam laws only tend to exist in sparsely populated jurisdictions. I think they break down if there are too many people.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by ryan_glass on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:56AM (#21640076)
Scotland has a right of access to land (including beaches) as well as inland water throughout the country. This is known as 'the right to roam' and is a good example of a jurisdiction where statutory right of access works well: https://www.scotways.com/faq/law-on-statutory-access-rights
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by smachiz on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:44AM (#21639940)
I'm not sure that's true. I'm pretty sure almost every state with beaches (inland or ocean) has laws that provide for public access to the beaches. How far reaching they are - and how they're enforced - would require more research.

http://www.beachapedia.org/Beach_Access

Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by ghaff on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:05PM (#21640859)
It's often in the form of public right to use the coastline below mean high water or something along those lines. However, that often does not include an automatic right to land access. The details vary mostly at the state level.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access by rjbwork on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:43AM (#21639921)
It's the purpose of the specific system of western capitalism's system of sole-ownership in perpetuity of private property.