Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by GrayShade on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:50AM
(#21636129)
That's... a year and a half.
Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by gwd on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @05:43AM
(#21637118)
Given that the advisory advises you update rather than stop using them, hopefully a year and a half to actually implement some sort of actual encryption. And hopefully the reporters were paid for "discussing technical details", like, how to actually use an encryption library.
Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by retSava on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:52AM
(#21637472)
Well, posting over HTTPS (with the worst certificates removed) instead of HTTP, perhaps with certificate pinning, isn't that hard and goes a long way.
Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by tialaramex on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:09AM
(#21638362)
This "XOR encryption" is vulnerable to an eavesdropper with almost no technical capability.
Even just HTTPS with no checks whatsoever (think 1990s Perl scripts or Python Requests with all the checking explicitly switched off) is protected against eavesdroppers, so that would require an active attacker (or a large quantum computer) to defeat, far more sophisticated than this trivial nonsense.
Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by retSava on Thursday November 28, 2019 @04:21AM
(#21655764)
Yeah exactly, that's my point - going from "oh shit" to "I feel fairly comfortable" in this case shouldn't take 1.5 years.
Re:FortiGuard XOR Encryption in Multiple Fortinet Products
by danmg on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:00PM
(#21643630)
This is the problem with 'responsible disclosure.' Companies will just drag their feet indefinitely, like an undergrad who stalls and manages to talk the instructor into assigning them an incomplete instead of just failing them outright. Just flunk them and don't reward that behavior: full disclosure.
Translation: half a year to communicate:
- you send it unecrypted
- yes we do.