News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by solipsism on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:18PM (#21625168)
everything that we have come to expect of all aspects of existence is only that way because it has been repeated enough to have been made a fact of reality

What does this even mean? Repeated enough to become a fact of reality? So before it was a "fact of reality" it was being repeated, but.. wasn't yet reality? Until it was repeated enough, and then it became a fact of reality?

Who is swayed by this kind of false deepness?

Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by michrassena on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:21PM (#21625433)
Ironic in light of your username, but what the comment you're responding to is talking about is the experience of reality rather than reality itself.

In the context of learning, and of survival, it's counterproductive for the brain to spend time and energy on outliers instead of what is consistent. The brain has a lot of innate capabilities at birth, but whatever reality the person experiences shapes them, whether it be language or culture. And unless the experience is traumatic, isolated instances get subsumed under the volume of everyday experience -- outliers are noise and repetition is signal.

Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by ozzmotik on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:33AM (#21625938)
yes this is precisely what I was talking about. I suppose that I could have been more clear or precise with how I worded my comment but i felt like it was clear enough that I wasn't necessarily talking about objective reality but rather the personal experience of reality. thank you for chiming in and clarifying for me, and thank you for making an attempt to understand what I was trying to say rather than taking every word at face value. nuance on the internet is definitely an NP-Hard problem, both transmitting and receiving it would seem.
Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by michrassena on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:02PM (#21634734)
I had a mild eureka moment when I read your initial comment. In a way it is obvious, how could things work otherwise? But linking reality (as a function of experience) and music is an interesting concept, and one I think has been explored quite a bit, but I've not seen anything to do with repetition being the binding concept.

I've recently become more interested in music which is probably why this resonated with me. A lot of the conventions of music, repetition included, I consider necessary evils. Like any creative endeavor, there is no correct music, but I see how it could be fruitful to explore this further.

[dead]
Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by michrassena on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:33PM (#21634483)
"things that look wrong, not like the norm"

What do you base your ideas of what is normal and what is not on?

Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by ozzmotik on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:05PM (#21631548)
so it's not possible for one complex system to act in two different, perhaps even contradictory ways, depending on context? I don't think anyone is making the claim that both the original claim and the opposite are true absolutely all the time and at the same time, but rather with the implicit suggestion that the brain, being a highly context sensitive organ, adjusts its modality relative to external input and at least attempts to use a relevant method when necessary, not just use both simultaneously all the time
Re:Repetition Makes Music Beautiful [video] by ozzmotik on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:31AM (#21625930)
as the response to your comment said, I indeed was speaking of the experience of reality rather than reality itself. I'm not entirely sure why you ask who is swayed by this sort of "false deepness" as to me that implies that I'm trying to inculcate others into my manner of thinking (which I suppose one could argue is a big aspect of rhetoric), when really the thing is is that I was just sharing what was on my mind in hopes of sparking a conversation with others who may or may not agree with me, hopefully to get their perspective and increase my understanding of how others experience reality. Which obviously happened seeing as you shared your perspective on it, so mission accomplished, I suppose. I just feel that the way you presented your perspective came across as unnecessarily hostile and almost as if you just found something you didn't like about the wording of it so you chose to dissect that and then use it as an example of what you would designate as "false deepness".

also: just because something has not yet been established as "fact" doesn't mean that it is not yet reality. merely that there is not an acceptable amount of certainty with regards to that pattern of behavior, or whatever the case may be, to establish it as a "normal" or "expected" manner in which reality might manifest. however, I'm fairly confident that even that verbiage won't be good enough as I wouldn't be surprised if you've already formulated a specific idea of who I am and what I'm trying to do by saying these things based off of your response :)