News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by nitwit005 on Saturday November 23, 2019 @10:26PM (#21618150)
I wouldn't assume it's a positive trait. People take pleasure out of things like optical illusions, which are arguably defects in human vision.

There is a 3-5% rate of people who don't enjoy music, and it at least doesn't obviously handicap them: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_anhedonia

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by pygy_ on Sunday November 24, 2019 @03:53AM (#21619214)
It doesn't handicap them today. I think it would have handicapped them 4000 years ago.

There is actual evidence for my theory BTW. Aboriginal folks in Australia had a tradition of using songs to describe itineraries.

Antique poetry and the bits of oral traditions that survived until today were using heavily structured verses (like the dactylic hexameter). A notable exception is the old testament, whose first parts were transmitted orally before being written down, and which is structured in verses of unknown structure (or unstructured, except for the psalms).

Modern poetry has gradually lost that strong structure. The prevalence of musical anhedonia and amusia may very well have risen in recent times as a result of the loss of utility of music.

————

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusia

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by nitwit005 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:24PM (#21622251)
Possibly, but it'd be a fairly minor handicap. Remember that people who don't enjoy music have no problem learning music or instruments, and plenty do. There's no obvious way it would result in your death.

We tend to make the mistake of assuming any seeming oddities of the human must somehow be due to evolution. But when we see the same in the rest of the body we often make the opposite assumption and assume it's a vestigial trait, or a coincidence.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by pygy_ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:21AM (#21626107)
My point is that taste in music is vestigial since the invention of writing. Before that it was a selective advantage.

Even if amusia (of which musical anhedonia is a subtype) was prevalent at the time, culture transmission operates at the group level. The mere existance of amusia with such a low prevalence doesn't invalidate my point.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by irrational on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:39AM (#21620663)
And thank goodness. I have musical anhedonia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_anhedonia), which basically means that music does nothing for me. I function just fine in today's society, where music is merely entertainment. I probably would've been screwed if I had been born thousands of years ago.
Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by andykx on Saturday November 23, 2019 @11:40PM (#21618387)
Are people really pleasured by optical illusions, or are they interested by them? I think that most people understand that their brains are struggling to comprehend them, and that is why they are interesting.

Regardless, I don't think there's much evidence (if any) for the idea that the enjoyment of music is the result of a defect in our auditory system.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by nitwit005 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:04AM (#21618709)
People certainly enjoy magic eye books and the like.

Defect would imply it's a negative trait. A lot of mental quirks are probably just irrelevant from an evolutionary point of view.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by Digit-Al on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:07AM (#21620826)
I would argue that magic eye books and optical illusions are different things. An optical illusion exploits our brains "shortcut" mechanisms, which could be considered taking advantage of a weakness, whilst a magic eye utilises our pattern matching ability, which could be considered as bolstering a strength.

Not sure I've explained myself as well as I could, but hopefully I have.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by nitwit005 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:34PM (#21622304)
Every optical illusion is some good aspect of vision failing in a limited case. Evolution is presumably selecting for the good aspect, and not the occasional hallucination it produces.