News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by atoav on Saturday November 23, 2019 @03:02PM (#21616162)
My theory is that this is due to the natural series of harmonics — sound tells you a ton about any physical object that emits it — so any oranism that lives in a sound transmitting medium profits from interpreting it and dividing it into different emotional responses. This is why a deep bass hit can feel dangerous, or exciting while a scraping metal sound can feel plainly wrong, because there is no harmony at all and this isn’t how anything is meant to sound at all.

So depending on what is dangerous or useful to a species it should develop different preferences.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by mrob on Saturday November 23, 2019 @04:55PM (#21616860)
Harmonic sounds (or approximately harmonic) are strong evidence that something evolved or was designed specifically for making sound. If you have an oscillator where the oscillation is constrained to one axis, e.g. an ideal string, reed, or column of air, it has only one degree of freedom. The state of the oscillator is fully described by its current position. It has no memory, so when driven in a steady state its behavior is identical every cycle. Even if its motion is non-linear, this will only cause anharmonic motion, not inharmonic, which is harmonic in the musical sense. The overtones must be integer multiples of the fundamental, because otherwise there would be different behavior on different cycles, which contradicts the single degree of freedom assumption.

But most natural objects have multiple degrees of freedom. If you hit a rock, stick, bone, etc. its oscillation is not constrained to a single axis. You can have multiple different unrelated frequencies. It's unlikely that all the prominent frequencies will be integer multiples of the fundamental by chance. To get harmonic sounds from a oscillator with multiple degrees of freedom takes skilled shaping of that object, e.g. tuning a bell by carefully shaving off metal at the right places.

Harmonic sounds are evidence of living creatures, and living creatures are potentially dangerous. Therefore it's not surprising that we're good at detecting them.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by dr_dshiv on Saturday November 23, 2019 @03:25PM (#21616308)
Also, more harmonics, more efficient sound production. And human voices are very harmonical. Sexual selection is likely responsible for that.

What I find strange, though, is why animals don't appreciate music (or almost never). You can't even train pigeons, nice or apes to tap to the beat.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by Jamwinner on Saturday November 23, 2019 @04:55PM (#21616861)
Consiciousness. I know its in vouge to pretend animals are all reasoning creatures, but alas the world is, thankfully, not disney. Our ability to relate 'Now', with our perception of stimulus moments ago, is how we percieve music. This is mostly absent in animals, or has a vastly different temporal range. Even pure tones are just cycles per second.

That said, if you ignore the meter, most animals seem to react to various harmonic and aharmonic sounds. Dogs howling, birds whistling, etc. The timings seem quite specific to the creature, and their adapted envirnment.

Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by cma on Saturday November 23, 2019 @04:21PM (#21616636)
Re:Music is universal and used in strikingly similar ways ac... by fenwick67 on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:48AM (#21620710)
Lots of parrots love music.