As you say, when the US police arrive at an active shooter situation a "GGWG" is very likely going to get killed if their gun is still visible.
There are drills for this, you know. Police aren't stupid. You can look up all the videos or reports you want, you will never find a civilian just standing there shooting at the bad guy, firefights are done in less than a few seconds.
Are you implying those 3.1+1.3=4.4% were meaningless and people should have simply given up and panicked? When talking about good guys with guns, what's the difference between a trained law-obiding citizen and a trained law-obiding law-enforcing citizen? You can call CCW course trainers and ask if it's good to be a hero.
Carrying guns is for self-defense, not self-offense. I'd say more than twice the off-duty cops is a good statistic.
There seem to be quite a few people using them in an offense-based capacity:
You can't really conclude that arms wouldn't be more useful in stopping active shooters.
That was my point, I was being ironic.
* https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/active-shooter-study-200... * https://crimeresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/U-_Acti...
In 5 cases (3.1%) armed civilians stopped the shooter, and in 2 (1.3%) there were off-duty police. Most shootings (90; 56%) ended because the shooter themselves stopped on their own.
While having a firearm may be handy, in the majority of cases it was not used, and probably not even "needed". Further, if there is an active shooter, and there is probably some level of chaos going on: how does a 'good guy with a good' (GGWG) distinguish between the attacker and another GGWG?
When the police arrive, how do they make the distinction? In the UK 7/7 attacks, an unarmed civilian was killed because the police thought he was one of the attackers:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Jean_Charles_de_Menez...