News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by arjunnarayan on Sunday January 30, 2011 @11:29PM (#2160267)
One of the key issues that I think has accompanied the downfall of the MBA is that the pure-boardroom corporate suit no longer delivers as much value as he used to. Sure, most big companies are run by corporate suits with MBAs, pedigree degrees and well-oiled networks of friends in management positions across the corporate world, but the primary metric used for rewarding management is growth.

While in the past, most companies grew under the direction and helmsmanship of a corporate suit A-list CEO, the return on investment is no longer there: 20 years ago, investors in a million dollar startup would get nervous and push for an MBA to steer the ship. When Google got big, there was a lot of clamoring from investors for "adult supervision". In contrast, while there were a few calls for Zuck to relinquish the helm to MBA-led adult supervision, he has resisted them while successfully growing his company to apparently a 50-billion dollar valuation. I only expect this trend to continue. The next big tech startup will never have a corporate non-tech type at the lead until it reaches it's current-day Microsoft-esque peak and slow decline. (One can argue that this is already the case, given that Eric Schmidt is actually a tech geek in corporate clothing.)

And this effect is not just at the top CEO-level: it is mirrored across the slightly lower tier of upper-management: the very tier that most aspiring MBAs hope to occupy at the pinnacle of their career. High performing tech departments are no longer being as gingerly managed by MBAs --- or if they still are, the leadership and powers are slowly being devolved more and more to the nerds. Quant managers in investment banks are already more compensated than the CEOs of those banks themselves. People no longer blink in horror when a boffin (what an antiquated and obsolete word!) is made a CEO.

Of course, most _mature_ well-established companies are and will probably continue to be run by MBAs in well-oiled corporate boardrooms. But the compensation is not the same for someone who takes a billion dollar company and grows it at 2% year on year as it is for someone who takes a 100 million dollar company and turns it into a billion dollar company.

In the past, MBAs used to be handed on a silver platter these gems in the rough by nervous investors eager to get some security (imagined or real) in their growth assets. This is no longer the case. And therefore, MBAs no longer have this easy source of high growth opportunities to lead to success. They are going to have to make these gems in the rough themselves, because those who are making the high growth companies are not relinquishing control (like Zuck.) to them to steer and get lavishly compensated for.

And if there's anything I've learned from the tech industry, it's that MBAs don't create value, aren't original, and don't actually start things --- and they are finally losing their cash cow of having high growth ventures handed to them. I wouldn't be surprised if in 10-20 years the MBA would either be radically different (evolved into a little corporate training and social skills for nerds seminar) or obsolete and viewed as a mature, well (but not outrageously so) compensated professional training programme like a degree in Accounting or Medical School. I have even bet on this being the case in choosing CS grad school over an MBA program in the recent past.

Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by yuhong on Monday January 31, 2011 @12:21AM (#2160394)
Yea, the myth that MBAs can manage everything have always been a myth, but it was very common during the shareholder value age when horrible stuff such as cutting costs were common. Now it seems like it is already dying.

"The next big tech startup will never have a corporate non-tech type at the lead until it reaches it's current-day Microsoft-esque peak and slow decline. "

And hopefully not even then.

Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by mickt on Sunday January 30, 2011 @11:43PM (#2160299)
All of your points are valid. But, for an individual who want to increase their perceived worth, and make more money, (even it's with a boring mature company) an MBA from a good school can't hurt, and is bound to teach some useful management skills.

MBA's from mediocre or unknown schools aren't going to get one a highfalutin job with some bank or the upper echelons of the S&P500, but they might teach some useful management skills and decisions making skills that could be useful to techie's and others who want to run their own companies.

Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by MichaelSalib on Monday January 31, 2011 @12:33AM (#2160415)
an MBA from a good school can't hurt, and is bound to teach some useful management skills.

I'm not so sure. Reading Henry Mintzberg's writings, one gets the sense that MBA programs are dangerous. They don't actually impart useful skills but they convince their students that they do. I mean, consider Harvard Biz school's case study methodology. You get a bunch of people who know nothing about a company or an industry to read 20 pages of material, reduce all its problems to a single strategic question, then pronounce a decisions and that's it -- this is like a parody for designing a process that allows ignorant people to screw things up, all the while relishing their elite ignorance.

Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by PakG1 on Monday January 31, 2011 @04:00AM (#2160793)
Being a published co-author of a business case (http://hbr.org/product/vidalia-onions-sweet-and-sour-transit...), I find this to be a strawman argument for decrying business cases. I get your underlying criticism about lack of domain expertise, but case study analysis never devolves into "single strategic question" situations. Usually, cases are just meant to exercise brains into trying to understand and analyze different situations and realize that the various tensions can actually be quite complex. The methodology has its faults, but let's (edit: not) make it out to be less than what it is. It helps people to get into the mindset necessary to make good managerial decisions in diverse situations. The key difference between case studies and real life is that case studies hand all the information to you on a silver platter, while in real life, managers need to go digging hard both inside and outside the company for all the information necessary for good decisions. Case studies never intend to cause managers to want to avoid listening to their employees, especially the ones who are domain experts. Such instances reflect more on the manager's incompetence than it does on the case study methodology's inability to teach.

As well, there's something good to be said about being able to bring in outside perspectives to right sinking ships, thanks to not being chained to pervasive biases that may unknowingly be held by those who were "insiders" for a while. IBM's perhaps one of the most extreme examples. They brought a CEO with a non-technology background to right the ship. And he did.

"In April 1993, IBM hired Louis V. Gerstner, Jr. as its new CEO. For the first time since 1914 IBM had recruited a leader from outside its ranks. Gerstner had been chairman and CEO of RJR Nabisco for four years, and had previously spent 11 years as a top executive at American Express. Gerstner brought with him a customer-oriented sensibility and the strategic-thinking expertise that he had honed through years as a management consultant at McKinsey & Co.. Recognizing that his first priority was to stabilize the company, he adopted a triage mindset and took quick, dramatic action. His early decisions included recommitting to the mainframe, selling the Federal Systems Division to Loral in order to replenish the company's cash coffers, continuing to shrink the workforce (reaching a low of 220,000 employees in 1994), and driving significant cost reductions within the company. Most importantly, Gerstner decided to reverse the move to spin off IBM business units into separate companies. He recognized that one of IBM's enduring strengths was its ability to provide integrated solutions for customers – someone who could represent more than piece parts or components. Splitting the company would have destroyed that unique IBM advantage.[25]"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_IBM

Not that John Sculley managed to do anything remotely as good for Apple when he was recruited by Jobs from Pepsi. ;)

Re:Why you shouldn't bother with an MBA by ojbyrne on Monday January 31, 2011 @08:42AM (#2161392)
Perhaps a valid criticism, but I'm not sure someone has developed a better alternative. I've seen too many "executives" whose decision making is based around

- superficial books they've picked up at the airport and read on the plane.

- soundbites they heard on cnn.com.

- random advice from other "executives" at parties.

Having been on both sides of case-based teaching, I'd say its a useful pedagogical device - imagining that 50 Harvard MBA students actually just "pronounce a decision" is kind of laughable, if you've ever participated in a case discussion. The cases are tools for discussion, and being able to convince others with a cogent powerful argument and build consensus is what is being taught. Something that is quite useful in management.

Not to mention that you get exposed to actual thinking beyond the "7 Habits of Highly Effective People" crap. My B-School experience actually included seeing Henry Mintzberg speak.