News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Functional Imperative Programming with Elixir (2018) by elcritch on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:59PM (#21600685)
It was a good read! Especially since you went through all the details. Handling different inputs and alternates like `after` are a bit tricky. And you're right on the downsides of the "stream" style. There's a bit of overhead compared to the macro form which can inline things a bit. It also takes a couple of more "cognitive" cycles to write, but usually I can read the results more quickly later.

In general I do wish Elixir provided a `reduce` macro similar to the for-loop one with the ability to halt. While-loop logic is easier to refashion as a reduce but it's harder to recall the argument orders for various Enum.reduce forms.

Do you use this while-macro in production code or just test code? Yah the "real" mutability tricks are more for those wondering if you _can_ do it. Sometimes it's not obvious, but one of the nice things in BEAM is that you can cheat.

P.S. thanks for all of your Elixir tools!

Re:Functional Imperative Programming with Elixir (2018) by bitwalker on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:25PM (#21612011)
> Do you use this while-macro in production code or just test code?

I use the `while` macro in the Distillery tests, since it made expressing certain tests much less verbose - namely those dealing with building up a release, spinning it up in a new node, and then verifying conditions on the running node meet expectations. In general though, I don't. I haven't needed it elsewhere (well, I have one other library I have considered using it in, but haven't yet). I would be hesitant to introduce it without a clear need, just because it would likely catch other developers off guard unless clearly documented.

To be clear though, I would support something like it in the language, but also understand why it isn't there; there just isn't a clear enough need, and as you've demonstrated, `Stream` can more or less be used to cover the general cases.

> P.S. thanks for all of your Elixir tools!

Thanks for the kind words!