News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by akdor1154 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:05AM (#21592752)
Jesus fuck this is disgusting.

Why do cries of "free market!!1" always seem to end up meaning "I want to profit at the expense of the public good"?

Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:05AM (#21594077)
> Why do cries of "free market!!1" always seem to end up meaning "I want to profit at the expense of the public good"?

Because market norms are so universally accepted in the West that the usual alternative to pure laissez-faire that “free market” arguments are deployed against is a market accompanied by regulation aimed at internalizing externalities, perhaps with socialization of a very narrow band of industry for which internalizing externalities in private trade is not seen as practical.

That is, it is usually deployed in situations where it can be seen as an argument for maintaining a situation where trade occurs with substantial unmitigated negative externalities over an alternative which addresses some of the negative externalities but otherwise preserves markets.

Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by vcavallo on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:24AM (#21594256)
describing this further in a clearer and simpler manner (or with examples) could be very helpful.
Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by dragonwriter on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:27AM (#21605779)
More clearly:

There's no significant push to move to anything except a market economy in the West (even most of the self-described “socialists” in the West want a market socialism, not a command economy), but there are simply efforts to make tweaks to mitigate what are perceived to be serious harms of un- or improperly-regulated markets without changing that the basic nature of the economy is market-based.

So, people might propose banning trade in a particular item that is seen as causing great harm external to those buying and selling it. Or might propose taxing it to fund harm mitigation, bringing the costs it involuntarily imposes on others into the trade transaction.

Or if a particular good is seen as essential but the market is widely seen as failing at delivering it, might propose socializing that industry (either health care or health insurance are common areas receiving that treatment in the developed West.)

So the cry of “free markets” in internal policy debates is never a rebuttal to an argument for a radically different economic system, but for minor tweaks to correct widely perceived serious harms from the existig market system. So, it has a tendency to seem to be “I want to profit at the expense of the public good”, because it only comes up when there is a debate because of a widespread concern that the profit motives driving the market are causing serious harm to the public good, and only as a defense against the proposed solution to that problem.

Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by iudqnolq on Thursday November 21, 2019 @04:06PM (#21599620)
I'm not entirely sure but I don't think their point - with econ terms removed - is particularly profound.

I think they're saying "the West" is so capitalist even the stuff people complain restricts free markets doesn't actually. If that's what they're saying I think they're wrong. For a good summary of why, see https://www.ndsu.edu/centers/pcpe/news/detail/32605/

Rephrased:

> Because market norms are so universally accepted in the West that the usual alternative to pure laissez-faire that “free market” arguments are deployed against is

The West is very pro market, so when people argue for free markets they are usually arguing against...

> a market accompanied by regulation aimed at internalizing externalities,

... making companies pay for the harms they cause (an example of internalizing a negative externality would be charging a factory for the CO2 they emit)

> perhaps with socialization of a very narrow band of industry for which internalizing externalities in private trade is not seen as practical.

... or maybe having the government own the company in the narrow spaces that makes more sense (probably they're referring to utility companies, but usually the argument for the government controlling that sort of company is slightly different)

>×That is, it is usually deployed in situations where it can be seen as an argument for maintaining a situation where trade occurs with substantial unmitigated negative externalities over an alternative which addresses some of the negative externalities but otherwise preserves markets.

In other words when people cry "free markets" they're usually arguing against solutions that would result in slightly regulated but free enough markets.

Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by vcavallo on Thursday November 21, 2019 @04:14PM (#21599695)
This is a very lovely response, thanks!
Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by wesammikhail on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:46AM (#21592931)
> Why do cries of "free market!!1" __always__ seem to end up meaning "I want to profit at the expense of the public good"?

Jeez, I wonder how many calories you burn each day by jumping into conclusions...

The entire internet was built by free market ethos in the sense that it was a network of people doing what they thought was best for them and their causes. But ofc, that´s not as important now is it? after all, once the fruits of the free market ripens, somehow the rules change and suddenly "public good" means whatever people want it to mean as long as it extracts value in their favor.

Now don´t get me wrong, I dislike this .org bullshit as much as the next guy, but imagine if I would have said:

Why do cries of "public good!!1" __always__ end up meaning "I want to abolish all profits and usher in the marxist utopia"?

It would be utterly stupid of me to say that because that is not the case, and the same goes for your statement.

Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by ausbah on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:16AM (#21593076)
The internet started as a government program, and so much for a "free market" when monopolistic ISPs control access to it.
Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by jon-wood on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:33AM (#21593131)
The Internet was built via a combination of defense funding and universities who thought it was a good idea. The free market didn't get involved until much later on in the process.
Re:Internet world despairs as non-profit .org sold to privat... by BLKNSLVR on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:08AM (#21593037)
> Why do cries of "free market!!1" __always__ seem to end up meaning "I want to profit at the expense of the public good"?

That matches the reality I've found myself reading about in the news for the last decade or so. Regular folk don't go declaring "free market", they don't need to, they just get on with things. It's those who feel they need to distract from or justify their actions that declare "free market" mainly because that shuts up the majority of critics who refuse to follow the money trail back to their sponsors.

Hypercapitalism and Piketty's "Capital in the Twenty-First Century" and all that.