News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by viraptor on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @03:16PM (#21577783)
> We tried a number of approaches to this problem, but each came with trade-offs in performance, security, features, or ease of use.

I wonder if they tried ZeroTier. It sounds really like what they wanted.

Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by zrail on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @03:55PM (#21578188)
They may have decided that ZT's encryption isn't proven well enough for their needs. It's also posssible they rejected ZT because they didn't want to use ZT's centralized infrastructure. Two years ago was long before ZT started working on making that optional.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by tiernano on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @04:03PM (#21578269)
ZT allows you to run your own "Moons", meaning you dont need their infrastructure... bit more config required on the client end, but less reliance on Zerotier....
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by zrail on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @04:31PM (#21578529)
Moons are going to be deprecated soon and as far as I understand never actually worked how people wanted. I.e. they still needed ZTs root servers, even if you were running your own controller.

To contrast, with Nebula you run your own root(s) (lighthouses) and you don't need a controller because important config (ip, group, hostname) is signed by the same CA.

Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by api on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @05:32PM (#21579038)
"Moons" are being deprecated in favor of true federation:

https://www.zerotier.com/zerotier-2-0-status/

https://www.zerotier.com/lf-announcement/

The moon terminology will also go away since there will no longer be a difference between these and our core roots. They'll all just be roots and will be interchangeable. The use of a common underlying key/value store will allow ZeroTier to keep its unified namespace and easy ability to join anyone's network or communicate with anyone regardless of what roots they're using (as long as their roots are on the same global network as you... obviously you can't hop air gaps).

Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by api on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @05:30PM (#21579022)
We are about to make that much easier and also allow true infrastructure federation -- you won't have to have your nodes contact our roots directly. We came up with something very interesting.

As for crypto: we plan some improvements in 2.0, but note that these days easily >90% of the traffic over ZeroTier networks (or any other VPN / overlay) tends to be already encrypted via SSH, SSL, etc. Another layer of encryption in the overlay just provides some additional defense in depth. We're rapidly moving to a world where everything layer 3 and above encrypts everything. That's why we have not prioritized sexier crypto for our L2 overlay tech. It's a bit redundant.

Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by artificialLimbs on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @11:21PM (#21581059)
OT: Thank you guys for the work you've been doing. Been using ZT for years and looking forward to root server decentralization.