News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Yuri Milner A Threat To Silicon Valley? by mindcrime on Saturday January 29, 2011 @04:56PM (#2156510)
But I don’t want Paul to be one of a small group of people who decides which companies get funding—not because he isn’t smart (he is) or a great guy (he is). When it comes to innovation, central decision-making is bad, no matter how good the decision-makers are.

I don't get this POV. It's not like YC is the only place to find companies that are worth funding by angels. Getting "pushed out" of the "YC ecosystem" is not the same thing as getting "pushed out" of the "startup ecosystem" as a whole. If you find that you can't invest in the YC companies anymore, find another incubator to work with, or deal with startups on an individual basis.

Re:Is Yuri Milner A Threat To Silicon Valley? by rodyancy on Saturday January 29, 2011 @06:27PM (#2156762)
Consider what this guaranteed $150k will do to other incubators. YC is going to be so much more attractive to other incubators, the best startups may not bother to apply to other incubators.

Sure, there will be winners that go through other incubators, or no incubator at all, but this is definitely going to tilt the field towards YC.

Re:Is Yuri Milner A Threat To Silicon Valley? by jacquesm on Saturday January 29, 2011 @08:06PM (#2156972)
YC still has limited capacity so that point is simply not valid. If you're not one of the lucky few to get in to YC and you want to do a start-up then you'll have to do without them.
Re:Is Yuri Milner A Threat To Silicon Valley? by sliverstorm on Saturday January 29, 2011 @05:55PM (#2156693)
It sounds like what he's saying is with a guaranteed $150k for every YC company, it's almost like Paul has the power to pick and choose which companies will get to succeed.

That is of course not the case, funding doesn't define success, but I gather that was his thought.

The silly thing of course is, if Milner was making the calls, nobody would have a problem with it.

Re:Is Yuri Milner A Threat To Silicon Valley? by jacquesm on Saturday January 29, 2011 @08:06PM (#2156977)
> The silly thing of course is, if Milner was making the calls, nobody would have a problem with it.

He's smart enough to get out of the way.