Re:Scapegoating free software’s failures
by StavrosK on Sunday November 17, 2019 @06:59PM
(#21560909)
That's an interesting license, thanks! I would have liked some examples about what exactly it does, because reading the text doesn't make all the ramifications clear, but it looks promising.
If some of the text is unclear, you can submit an issue on the license' GitHub repository. Kyle (the creator of the license) considers this an issue with the license, and is very open to improve the text to eliminate any such issues readers have.
Re:Scapegoating free software’s failures
by StavrosK on Monday November 18, 2019 @07:08AM
(#21563643)
I will, thanks. It's not unclear in a legal way, just in a human "what can my users/forkers/etc do with this license" way (which may still be a valid issue to open).
Isn't Parity License a source-available share-alike freeware license? It seems very different from GPL and even the ideas by which copyleft was originated.
Would you care to elaborate? To me, it seems very much in the 'spirit' of what GPL set out to do back when, updated to eliminate issues that weren't/couldn't have been forseen. Parity is not perfect (yet), but to me it's the most viable attempt at a modern copyleft license to date.
Technically, one can argue Parity is not 'open source', if one acknowledges that only OSI approved licenses should be called 'open source'. I don't, and quite a few other folk don't either. Lots of people do, though.
To me it seems very unclear what this license means in practical terms. It mentions that contributions are needed unless it's prototype but definitions on what it means isn't there. Can you operate gmail-type of service, call it beta and not release the code for many years because it's "used for for non-production user testing"?
It's interesting in that it doesn't try to prescribe the license downstream projects use as long as it's free (in contrast to for example GPL) but is, at the same time, very strict in regards to when it applies (basically every time Parity-licensed code 'touches' non-free software), which means there is no Saas loophole for example.