Re:“What Alan Kay Got Wrong About Objects”
by mpweiher on Sunday November 17, 2019 @05:48PM
(#21560547)
Blind worship is always wrong. However, most admiration for Alan Kay's work is by knowledgeable people and for good reasons. Including the committee that decides on Turing awards...
I am quite certain that my admiration for the man and his work is not blind.
And do note that I described his construction as "brilliant" in my post, despite the fact that he ultimately got that part wrong.
Re:“What Alan Kay Got Wrong About Objects”
by t-h-e-chief on Sunday November 17, 2019 @05:47PM
(#21560540)
Ah. Alan Kay himself said that he feels they got the boundaries/sizing wrong when designing OO, so there really shouldn't be any mention of 'blind worship'. As far as I am aware, Kay has never been caught up in his own hubris.
You're being downvoted (as I expect I will be, for agreeing with you), but having lived through the time when people blindly worshiped Alan Kay, I could not agree more with this statement.