News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter: The Shallowness of Google Translate (... by glenstein on Sunday November 17, 2019 @10:28AM (#21558315)
Hofstadter is trying to draw a conceptual distinction between "understanding" (generating language by drawing from a full interiority of human subjective experience), and mere "translation" (based on looking at words).

But analyzing how words are used is a great way of working backward into something that gets closer and closer to human subjectivity. Some neural net trained on how words are used would start to model concepts that reflect "under the hood" human experiences that generate language.

Maybe it's not 'enough', and a robust translation engine would have a sense of irony, jealousy, favorite foods, etc that it would need to rely on to translate things, and maybe that set of concepts to be obtained via something other than training on words. But I don't think there's a clear conceptual line to be drawn. Studying the way we use words can get us a loose approximation, maybe even a good one.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: The Shallowness of Google Translate (... by Mathnerd314 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @01:32PM (#21559227)
The Chinese example at the end where he had to look up the phrase himself (on Google) is particularly revealing. Humans don't have any more insight into words than the machine. They're just better at interpreting explanations written by humans and intended for humans.