A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Driving Car Future

Re:A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Dr... by l3robot on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:32PM (#21554155)

Not also to mention something often oversight. An autonomous car can park far away from it's user, meaning we could drastically reduce de number of space taken by parking in the city. First, giving back this spaces to the people as green parks and services places. Second, lower one of the biggest problem in our current city: urban heat island.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Dr... by amarshall on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:39PM (#21554195)

But then you’ll likely have a bunch of extra traffic created from the cars going to and from their owner to parking, rather than just to and from their destination. Or from the car just circling the block because the owner would rather not have to wait long for its return.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Dr... by jellicle on Saturday November 16, 2019 @04:36PM (#21555125)

Right. You go to the opera, you order the car to drive around the block for two hours and then pick you up. Cost of gas is cheaper than parking and by definition, you're not affected by any traffic congestion caused as you're sitting watching your show. Sure, 1000 other people in the theater are also doing it, but that's not your problem.

30 minutes before the show is over, you order the car to wait in the "no stopping" zone in front of the theater for easy access. You exit the theater and find your car is tangled in a mess of traffic that takes 45 minutes to clear as most of the cars are double-parked and blocking traffic, waiting for their owners. For the duration of the show, no useful traffic has been able to move for a mile in any direction, as empty cars are just idling around and are content to wait, fully stopped.

Tragedy of the commons.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Dr... by alasdair_ on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:10PM (#21554330)

The “circling the block” is something that Uber etc. already exacerbate.

I think one solution would be to charge for each minute you are in a congested area to avoid having a whole bunch of empty cars clogging the streets.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:A Week with Chauffeurs Showed the Major Flaw in a Self-Dr... by CydeWeys on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:22PM (#21554390)

There's a big limit on how bad it can be with Uber though because each Uber is currently driven by an actual person. That person costs money and places a natural limit on how many unutilized Ubers there will be.

With AVs, this limit no longer exists, and people will start using AVs for runs that currently are prohibitively expensive with care that require drivers.

[ Parent | on HN ]