News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against Economics by aazaa on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:14AM (#21552479)
> Printing money does not cause inflation.

Ah, but it does. It creates asset inflation. This may be the worst kind of all possible inflation because it makes people believe they are wealthier than they are. When the inflation can no longer be sustained, large numbers will soon find out they are far poorer than they once thought. That's the stuff of revolutions and Dark Times.

Asset inflation takes root through policies that distribute money, not to the poor (Great Society), but to the rich (Deregulation and Quantitative Easing). The rich have no use for the money being given out and so drive up asset prices with it.

From this perspective, it's easier to see how a multi-thousand word essay on new economics fails to mention negative interest rates once.

Re:Against Economics by cryptica on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:26AM (#21552517)
I agree with your point about asset inflation but I think that the author of the article is well aware of it based on these lines:

> Doubling the amount of gold in a country will have no effect on the price of cheese if you give all the gold to rich people and they just bury it in their yards, or use it to make gold-plated submarines (this is, incidentally, why quantitative easing, the strategy of buying long-term government bonds to put money into circulation, did not work either). What actually matters is spending.

Are you suggesting that negative interest rates are some kind of solution? I think they would make the problem worse, just like QE; the effect would just be to expand the money supply by injecting more money into the economy on the basis of arbitrary rules.

With negative rates, the incentive becomes that everyone should borrow all the time (because borrowing becomes profitable), so then the question will quickly become "who is allowed/qualified to borrow?" and the answer will either be "rich people" or some other kind of unfair arbitrary criteria.

Negative interest rates are a terrible idea. All the extra money will be absorbed by cryptocurrencies, advertising platforms and other speculative investments.

Re:Against Economics by panarky on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:13PM (#21553666)
> What actually matters is spending

Exactly right.

  MV = PT
Where M is the monetary base, V is the velocity of money, P is the price level, and T is the real value of transactions.

Central banks would love it if they could precisely control inflation by creating and destroying money.

What actually happened with QE is that M increased and V decreased in almost the identical magnitude, leaving P and T virtually unchanged.

Central banks have very little influence over the real economy, aside from short-term changes in interest rates.

Re:Against Economics by snidane on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:31AM (#21552526)
This is the big flaw in how inflation is measured. Assets (eg. for pension savings) and especially housing costs are for some reason not included in the Consumer Pricing Index despite them being a huge expense from person's monthly paycheck.

One can argue the reasons why. Is of the same problem with KPIs in general thay we only measure things which are easy to measure and omit the difficult but often much more important things to measure?

Or is it a conspiracy plot in which the governments realized that the only way to repay those ever increasing government debts is by inflating them away. Ie. borrowing at 1% akin to CPI reported inflation instead of at 8% which is what the actual inflation might be.

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:41PM (#21554205)
Your basic assumption here is not true. The CPI includes housing costs. Here is how the BLS calculates housing costs for the CPI in great detail: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an...
Re:Against Economics by ianai on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:54AM (#21552625)
Putting on my academic Econ hat for a moment: There’s probably a stronger argument for including housing costs like rent into CPI than asset value like home values. Assets like homes are supposed to be illiquid and relatively constant over time. Ie little change in the underlying fundamentals of the item or changes that can be accounted for in an uncomplicated way. When such stable in underlying value but relatively illiquid assets like homes trade their realized prices are supposed to reflect little more than inflation. So maybe their price changes make more sense on the exogenous side of the equation than the endogenous?

Is this argument still valid? It seems like it would be since it still seems moving in and out of a mortgage is a longer (by months) process than moving in or out of a lease.

Re:Against Economics by ianai on Saturday November 16, 2019 @09:00AM (#21552647)
Replying to myself to avoid an edit as this is a new topic.

I’m wondering increasingly lately if oil hasn’t replaced gold and fiat as the underlying backer value of currency. We had a problem in Econ to contrast and compare fiat currency to gold backed currency. Fiat is supposed to not be tied to a scarce resource and thus central banks have the ability to influence market growth through currency growth. Gold or resource backed currency can only grow at the rate new stock is removed from the ground. Of course, oil complicates there concept as oil is irreversibly consumed when it’s burned. The value of it still greatly affects market growth potentials though.

Re:Against Economics by derefr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @11:41AM (#21553510)
The difference with oil is that not everybody exports it. With the gold standard, every sovereign nation worth the name attempted to create a gold-backed sovereign currency, and so was essentially “exporting gold” in some sense (the sense in which you can take their currency outside the country and spend it.)

But not all countries are oil exporters, or oil “holders”; and even those who are, are not exporters to the same order-of-magnitude. This creates very clear market effects where e.g. the value of the Canadian dollar at any time is essentially the value of the US dollar divided by the quantity of US oil exports.

This would be like different gold-backed sovereign nations declaring a different, floating “ratio” of their fiat currency’s value to their level of gold deposits, such that changes in the price of gold would throw exchange rates around (and some nations having no gold at all, and thus having an exchange rate that measures only how much of some other country’s gold their fiat currency could buy you!)

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:43PM (#21554213)
CPI does include rent. For houses that people own outright, the BLS tries to back out an implied rent.
Re:Against Economics by derefr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @11:37AM (#21553481)
I think (Core) CPI is what it is because many things carry an inflationary signal, but very few things have no other signals mixed in as noise. Core CPI isn’t quite “measuring what is easy to measure”, but rather “measuring what is least distorted by other pressures on the market” (because goods like food and clothing are both easy-enough to produce and in high-enough demand that there is almost always an efficient market for them.)

You can then use the inflation signal from Core CPI to correct other measures for inflation, in order to see what those other measures are doing beyond just inflating. (Maybe they’re doing something like “inflation squared”, but that’s still a separate thing, which you still need a measure of base-term inflation to find out!)

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:51PM (#21554238)
There's no such thing as asset price inflation -- it's a pre-modern Austrian notion. The value of an asset is the discounted value of its future cash flows (the net present value). If an asset is worth more than its future cash flows, then you have an asset price bubble.

The rich think they are rich because they actually are rich, and they expect to be rich in the future. The value of the stock market is high because profits are high, and the owners of stock expect them to remain high. They could be overoptimistic about the future, but its driven by future expectations about the real economy.

Re:Against Economics by corporate_shi11 on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:39PM (#21554816)
What are the future cash flows of a stock with no dividend?

They are 0. Does that mean that all stock price inflation for such securities is just a bubble? Of course not.

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:47PM (#21554858)
Stock buybacks also count as cash flows. But stock that will never pay a dividend (or do a buyback) in a million years? That is as pure a bubble as you will ever find.
Re:Against Economics by wallacoloo on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:59PM (#21554915)
Isn’t it reasonable to consider a company’s assets in addition to cash flows? If a company has $1B of assets (and no loans, for simplicity), might indirect ownership/control over those assets via stock be worth something?
Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @04:22PM (#21555034)
That's actually a really good point. But you have to be able to eventually convert the assets into cash (maybe through selling the assets to another company, rather than through dividends).
Re:Against Economics by aww_dang on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:44AM (#21552578)
Speaking from the Austrian perspective, the original definition of inflation is an inflation of the money supply. Price inflation is a separate but associated phenomenon.