News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crgwbr on Friday November 15, 2019 @08:55AM (#21544760)
Wouldn’t an easy non-law compromise here be to reword questions slightly? For example, instead of asking “How did humans come into existence?” ask “According to the theory of evolution, how did humans come into existence?“ That would accurately test a student’s knowledge of what was taught without requiring them to agree with the answer.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by yawboakye on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#21544921)
Bias: I'm Christian.

This is probably the best contribution anyone made to the conversation. The role of faith in a person's life cannot be diminished, especially where the scientific option is contested. I belong to a Christian denomination that doesn't believe in The Trinity. I never answered questions about it that implied that it was the belief I held. I didn't mind writing essays on it though when the question started with "According to the trinity doctrine, ..."

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:19AM (#21544958)
> especially where the scientific option is contested

There’s no contention on evolution. That’s like saying the equivalent...

“According to the theory of gravity, apples fall to earth...”

Couching all these questions as if they are not facts does nothing but ease people’s minds who don’t want to deal with reality, and does a disservice to students.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by phy6 on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:40AM (#21545698)
I used to feel this way, until I read the book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn. The author points out correctly that too often the arrival of our current state of scientific beliefs from the past is drawn out as a straight line, and that the history of what was 'scientific truth' for a time was altogether forgotten or not taught. The easiest(), most respectful and accurate solution is to always couch a belief from the context and ontology of where it came from, including religious, scientific and personal beliefs.

As I become more learned with age, I find no greater delight than being humbled by how little we can actually claim to know. In my opinion this humility should be used for our advantage: by the small burden of contextualizing the origins and boundaries of a [scientific] belief, I think we prime ourselves for accelerating cross domain scientific revolutions. Referencing the origins of belief systems is a practice we can employ to benefit future understanding.

I'd argue the same is true for someone who studies multiple religions and their various interpretations. How would they arrive at any greater understanding without having references to the origins of groups of belief?

easiest from a strategic perspective of increasing the rate of scientific revolution. There is of course a short term burden of contextualizing beliefs.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by davvolun on Friday November 15, 2019 @12:36PM (#21546837)
This is generally true, but also completely irrelevant to the ""debate"" on evolution. Scientific humility is an important quality, but it's misleading to young kids; and fundamentally works against understanding the "cross domain scientific revolutions." Until you're prepared with the ground work to understand why Newtonian physics isn't quite right (at really small or really big sizes), a rigorous introduction to relativity is just confusing.

Just like we don't have elementary kids read Kant despite the eventual value (when they're prepared for the intellectual rigor), evolution questions should not be given to 14-17 year old kids as qualified "according to the theory of evolution." Maybe 18 -- it's a tough question that depends on individual kids' capabilities.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by gatherhunterer on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:07AM (#21544847)
If it is a biology class then it is inherently an evolution class. Evolution is the central theory of biology and all of its sub-fields.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by neuronic on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:17AM (#21544946)
Not for at least half the planet. Facts and reality aren't important or something to even consider.

Observing the exposure of these widespread thought processes by means of social media has truly and deeply disturbed me. There is a good, solid chunk of people who are absolutely not interested in learning or having their minds changed.

I am German and went to a US college where I observed students jumping out from their seat, yelling at a lecturer that they need to include God and his creation stuff in biology lectures.

I was truly baffled. In Germany, we have some of the most persistent anti-scientific and conspiracy communities as well. Especially anti-vaxers, chem trails, and anti-electromagnetic radiation folks.

As a student, my landlord had a radiation shield built on top of electric wiring in the basement. It was a painted brick from some website making bank off of idiots.

And don't forget homeopathy and how politics even financially supports it.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by dna_polymerase on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:59AM (#21545870)
> Homeopathy

Ah yes. The multi-million Euro industry that sells the placebo effect in bottles.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by __MatrixMan__ on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#21544914)
It's the dominant theory, and it's a darn good one, but isn't that a bit like saying that all geometry is euclidean geometry?
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:37AM (#21545112)
No... not even close.

If interested why, there’s lots of reference material:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/1416594795/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_.F...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:14AM (#21558529)
I didn't read the book, but the Wikipedia article doesn't have anything to say regarding the domains of biology that might be well explained by other theories.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by Balgair on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:41AM (#21545136)
Not really. Everything, except maybe the physical-chemistry reactions, is there due solely to evolution. No evolution, no molecules. To translate (very poorly and grossly) to math, it's like all operations are evolution, only the numbers aren't.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:09AM (#21558503)
Just to be nitpicky: the carbon dioxide molecules in the atmosphere of Mars (probably) have nothing to do with evolution. Unless you're a fan of cosmological natural selection (which I happen to be, but it's not a widely accepted theory).

Anyhow, without evolution we would still have all of those things, we wound have just lost our ability to tell a convincing story for why they are the way they are.

It seems unlikely, but if an alternative explanation were too arise and be deemed more useful by biologists, then the study of that theory would also be biology.

In fact, it would still be biology if it were deemed less useful, it just might not make it into the textbooks in that case.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by ppod on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:20AM (#21544967)
I think a problem with this approach is that since it doesn't ask for the student's actual belief, the student might score highly but still hold beliefs that may be dangerously wrong when used in a practical situation.

For example, a student may give a correct answer to this question, but when employed as doctor and prescribing a treatment (e.g. for contraception, pregnancy issues, heritable diseases) they may act according to their beliefs rather than the theory they were asked about, with dangerous consequences.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by cptskippy on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:32AM (#21545071)
Couldn't you then ask if the individual is willing to practice the prescribed belief over their own?
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by leetcrew on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#21544920)
this seems reasonable. perhaps all science questions should be asked this way. it would be a subtle reminder that what you are learning is only the best current explanation, not the absolute truth of the universe. a lot of material you learn in grade school is simplified to the point of being almost wrong anyway.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by mattigames on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:23AM (#21545000)
That seems like a handwavy way to disregard the way that theory came to be, meaning that instead of "According to theory of evolution" a more honest complete question would be "According to all the evidence we have acquired over the last few centuries in the fossil record thanks to the studies of hundreds of anthropologists and biochemists how did humans come into existence?"
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by moccachino on Friday November 15, 2019 @08:58AM (#21544778)
According to my belief system any mention of evolution is blasphemy so I can not answer this question.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by Humdeee on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:05AM (#21544833)
Any answer of mine that is marked incorrect will be withdrawn and the question subtracted from the overall marking grade. Due to my religious beliefs.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by flattone on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:07AM (#21544852)
Essentially: Due to my religion I will be president.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by gowld on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:09AM (#21544875)
Yes, if people followed the law independent of the law, the law would not be needed. This holds in general.

The law is to protect students against anti-religious teachers who punish students for making religious statements.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by uryga on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:28AM (#21545045)
> The law is to protect students against anti-religious teachers who punish students for making religious statements

idk, it seems more aligned with protecting the weird thing some USA¹ Christians do where they take the Bible as historical fact re: creation of the world...

quoting the article:

> students can't be penalized if their work is scientifically wrong as long as the reasoning is because of their religious beliefs.

is science class really the place to do that? are we cool with Ohio children being unfamiliar with evolutionary theory because of their religion?

---

1. i'm not sure if singling out the USA is correct here, but it's the only country where i've seen this. even here in Poland, where a lot of people are seriously religious (Christian), this sort of thing doesn't seem to happen

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by XCabbage on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:47AM (#21545196)
Read the bill instead of blindly believing the article. The article is lying outright about what the bill says. Not only does it not require teachers to accept religiously-based scientifically incorrect answers, it outright forbids them from doing so, requiring them instead to grade such answers based on "legitimate pedagogical concerns". The article - and your take based on the article - are the complete opposite of the truth.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by mattigames on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:13AM (#21544907)
The law may be intended for that, the actual consequence is disregarding facts as if where opinions and growing up believing doing so its Ok.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by hhas01 on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:21AM (#21544980)
You mean students making religious statements like “2π = 6”?

Yeah that’s definitely not right, the correct solution of course being “Burn the mathematician^W witch!”

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#21544911)
Why does there need to be a law to protect students who provide incorrect answers?

I guess we need a law to protect students from having to read controversial books too?

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by yawboakye on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:16AM (#21544935)
Because, well, there's no correct answer. Only what's less wrong. Asimov explains better https://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.ht...
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @12:21PM (#21546672)
BTW... Asimov is rolling in his grave that you used his article this way. You’ve completely and totally missed the point. It doesn’t mean there’s “no correct answer” lol.

“I had expressed a certain gladness at living in a century in which we finally got the basis of the universe straight.”

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by yawboakye on Friday November 15, 2019 @03:25PM (#21548397)
You’re right. Now go enjoy your day!
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @09:28AM (#21545042)
Tests don’t need to grade “maybe a tiny tiny tiny bit wrong” from “horribly horribly wrong and misinformed”

Evolution is not contested in the slightest. Should we grade tests to allow students to believe that things fall up?

If you think that’s hyperbole then that’s the problem right there. The whole evolution debate is so tiring.

Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by yawboakye on Friday November 15, 2019 @03:31PM (#21548446)
It wasn’t Newton’s theory that taught us that things fall down. It’s pretty a gutter material to compare observation/reality with a theory that spans eons, a duration no one has lived entirely. That said, if the theory of evolution gives meaning to your life, makes you a good person, and opens your eyes to appreciate everything and everyone around you, in other words, if it’s your sustenance then definitely hold on to it. Because, imo, that’s what life is about. But let others find theirs and enjoy their short time here.
Re:Ohio bill would allow students to be scientifically wrong... by crazydoggers on Friday November 15, 2019 @05:47PM (#21549520)
Just don’t make public policy decisions that effect me and my children, or vote for people who don’t want to teach science, evolution, etc in schools.

You don’t just enjoy your life when you do that, but actively work at destroying others.