News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against Economics by nlfwhulsdhouv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @08:13PM (#21541371)
I'm not claiming they require "clean experimental results" for the field to have validity. I think sociology is a very valid and valuable field that doesn't have such a thing.

My problem is the misrepresentation of a sociology-like field as experimental physics, or worse, a study of morality. Both are exceptionally common in economics, and I've had several teachers and professors present it that way. It's the orthodoxy surrounding a very specific, Reagan-era capitalist interpretation of the function and behaviour of a society taught as a universal law.

Re:Against Economics by hogFeast on Thursday November 14, 2019 @08:39PM (#21541505)
It isn't like sociology...you either haven't studied economics or sociology.

And I would agree generally but I think your reasoning is wrong. Economics of itself dictates no outcome. This is an argument that sociologists often make (i.e. the person uses the tool but the tool also uses the person) but, ironically, this is an example of trying to universalise a principle of sociology to an area where it doesn't really apply. Why? Because if you want to value any end...just build a model that does so.

And btw, arguments generally about the function of a society are politics. You will find this kind of thing taught in politics, not economics. Economists can have a view on them but you have to use politics to demonstrate that any goal of society is better than any other...which is inherently subjective anyway. Ironically, the main people who complain about economics having an orthodoxy about the function of society generally have fairly rigid ideas on this topic already.

Re:Against Economics by nlfwhulsdhouv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @08:51PM (#21541574)
> It isn't like sociology...you either haven't studied economics or sociology.

I love this dig specifically because you missed my point. I was simply addressing the fact that I don't think a field needs to have experimentation to have value.

> And btw, arguments generally about the function of a society are politics.

No shit.

> Because if you want to value any end...just build a model that does so.

> Economists can have a view on them but you have to use politics to demonstrate that any goal of society is better than any other.

That's exactly my point. Economists conflate their model of Western Capitalism (for better or worse) with a moral position or _necessary_ condition for society.

I know their are economists that don't do this, but none I've met or been taught by.

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:33PM (#21551032)
Study of morality? You have weird economics professors.
Re:Against Economics by Gibbon1 on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:35PM (#21551038)
I read an abstract of a sociology paper. The authors tested economics students as beginning freshmen and then four years later. The test measured sociopathy. You can guess.
Re:Against Economics by sokoloff on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:42AM (#21552567)
My first guess is they found an increase. A close second guess is they didn’t have appropriate controls in the study to draw a valid conclusion.