- Backpacking for one night: Probably just phone (I use an app called Offline Topo Maps, works great).
- Backpacking for an extended amount of time: Paper
- Backpacking in winter/snow: Paper and Phone. (Only use the phone for when I'm not quite sure where I am)
- Motorcycle tour: Phone.
- Multiday rafting: Paper.
- Bicycle Tour: Phone and Paper.
- General Travel to a new place: Phone.
I feel as if one isn't necessarily better than the other, they both have their pros & cons for different activities.
Get out of cell phone service, which isn't uncommon in rural America...or lose the charge on your phone...and wind up on a winding country road...and see how well you can get yourself to civilization.
Two is one and one is none. With the way we depend on technology, it seems that society is always one power outage away from chaos.
I'm like you, too. I have an awesome Harley-Davidson map book that has complete maps of almost all highways in the entire USA, state by state. Also has maps of large metro areas in it, too.
Additionally, I always buy one of those NatGeo maps for wherever I'm going hiking/backpacking/camping (typically nat'l parks/monuments, but also Nat'l forests, state parks, etc.)
With these, I'm always prepared for no cell service.
I do not recall ever having drained my cell battery completely. And I have a car charger.
There are reasons to keep paper maps around, but lack of signal and running out of battery aren't on the list.
Driving directions: turn left at C509 (unmarked) for 2.9 miles. The exchange is past the creek. There will be big puddles, plow through them.
Problems happen when you're in a Honda civic that can't go through 2.5 feet of water. So you have to turn around and find your own way to the exchange, with no cell service.
We always bring multiple copies of a Michigan Atlas. This way we can pinpoint where we are (using GPS) and find nearby roads, despite the terrible race directions.
Getting caught with a GPS-capable device on the land nav course was considered cheating.
Paper maps have a consistency and security no digital navigation device I ever owned or saw ever had.
I realize this is a kind of "get off my lawn" argument one could also make about digital vs analog newspapers, or books.
The key is: If my Kindle decides to do some weird updating and requires re-downloading all my books, well I guess I won't read on my subway ride home. If my map does that in northern Scandinavia, well now I am fucked.
Just print 5 maps and laminate them and you're pretty safe against weather and time. Not so much with a digital map.
Print something and it will show that print as long as it is not physically destructed. Not so much with a digital map ("oh, our services don't work in this country ha ha. Did you not read the t&c?")
Sun glare. Off the grid for three weeks. Weight. None of this is a problem with analog maps.
I guess you can solve most of these problems by throwing lots of money at god knows what military/navy device, thus I specified non-rich people. Or you know, just use a paper map.