Do you see the same kind of risk problems in the muni bond space? For instance: PZA, MLN, FCAVX all show that they're 100% investment grade. Are these among the funds that are actually more risky than they appear?
What's your opinion on CEF Muni bond funds like: MYD, IIM, VGM, NVG, NAD, MHI. I know they're relatively risky but should do fine as long as the world isn't completely falling apart. I've seen some professionals say the credit markets are kind of binary. When things are good, they're always going up. And when things get really bad, everyone wants to sell at once. is this true of muni bonds as well?
As I understand it, there are legal agreements that take ratings as an input (e.g. a pension may only invest in investment grade bonds).
But is there actually any way for a consumer to sue Morningstar? Or are their ratings essentially just "proprietary numbers", no warranty given?
The sellers of the debt, or financial products, are the ones that pay the ratings agencies, so they are the real customers.
The buyers should be doing due diligence, especially considering the conflict of interest, but they are also frequently agents on behalf of taxpayers (for government pensions) or other far removed investor, so agency risk is big here too.
The lack of accurate risk (reflected by the average bond ratings of your holdings) is what is really at the core of this argument. The researchers joined together some pretty commonly used datasets in the industry (probably what I would use if I were to do this) and impressively were able to properly take the holdings of managers and come up with a proper risk picture (if you believe that rating agency ratings of bonds reflects the true risk but that for another post). Morningstar basically said that they have a crappy dataset which just doesn't have rating data for many bonds and therefor, when they don't have a value, they just fill in with a default. This makes me think that Morningstar is doing a pretty lazy job in their evaluation of managers (what incentive do they really have, they are a monopoly in this area).
Happy to answer any questions people have.