News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Take Their Word for It: The Misclassification of Bo... by jawns on Thursday November 14, 2019 @09:41AM (#21535683)
That's quite a response! It sounds as if the authors of the paper would have done well to verify some of their factual assumptions with Morningstar prior to publication.

Some key points from the response:

On the apparent discrepancy between Morningstar's data and self-reported data:

> Because Morningstar’s proprietary methodology for calculating Average Credit Quality particularly penalizes unrated holdings by assigning them a low rating (B or BB), it is not surprising that the authors would find Morningstar’s calculated data to produce a lower average credit quality than self-reported data. When we control for not-rated holdings, we do not find a similar pattern.

How category classification is assigned:

> Throughout the paper, the authors conflate where a fund lands in the Fixed-Income Style Box with its Morningstar Category. In reality, Morningstar’s Fixed-Income Style Box assignment and Morningstar Categories are distinct. Morningstar does not use a fund’s Morningstar Fixed-Income Style Box assignment to determine its category classification.

How star rating is assigned:

> A fund’s star rating is calculated based on past performance relative to peers in its Morningstar Category – rather than relative to funds that share its Fixed-Income Style Box placement, as described above.

There are no comments on this comment yet.