Re:Would-Be Suicide Bomber Killed by Unexpected SMS From Mob...
by charlief on Friday January 28, 2011 @03:37PM
(#2153424)
It is a good idea, but I feel that your first-five-upvoter share is too strong of an incentive. It will encourage upvoting for the sake of karma rather than to reflect the overall quality of the article. There could be up-vote spam. It could also come in the form of vote herding on the new page because once an article has 2-3 points, there will be a rush for the remaining 4-5 slots. The result is a more cycled-through front page with worse quality articles.
Re:Would-Be Suicide Bomber Killed by Unexpected SMS From Mob...
by jmilloy on Friday January 28, 2011 @04:38PM
(#2153630)
Ha... so you need give people karma if they voted early (in the first 5) on an article that becomes popular, and penalize them for voting early on an article that goes nowhere once it's on the front page.
Re:Would-Be Suicide Bomber Killed by Unexpected SMS From Mob...
by billswift on Friday January 28, 2011 @05:49PM
(#2153835)
It would be simpler to just give the first 5 or whatever upvoters a bonus based on the total upvotes the article receives, if someone decided to do something like that.
Re:Would-Be Suicide Bomber Killed by Unexpected SMS From Mob...
by Retric on Friday January 28, 2011 @11:32PM
(#2154631)
That would result in people up voting every story.
Re:Would-Be Suicide Bomber Killed by Unexpected SMS From Mob...
by MichaelApproved on Saturday January 29, 2011 @04:38AM
(#2155136)
How about showing a random new article on the front page?
Since stories usually hit the front page when their score is around 6, I think it would make sense to give the first five upvoters a share of the karma from the submission. (With the submitter getting the most, and the first upvoter getting more than the fifth.)