News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general int... by solipsism on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:59PM (#21532910)
For any interactive reward-giving environment E, you could place X into E and see how much reward X gets; likewise for Y. If X gets more reward, you can consider that as evidence of X being more intelligent.

That's an odd definition of intelligence. By that definition, a bird is more "intelligent" than a human at the task of opening a nut. Seems like "fitness" would be a much more appropriate term.

It seems especially strange to consider this work in the field of general intelligence. Nothing about what you just described is general. By this definition, a chess bot is much more intelligent than the average person. I don't think we'd say a chess bot has general intelligence.

Re:John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general int... by NateEag on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:55AM (#21534993)
I think the idea is that you would have many environments and each one is a voter.

If an AGI candidate wins the board game vote but no others (the hunter-gathering vote, the walking and crawling vote, the "publish or perish" vote, etc), it will be trounced by something that is not quite so good at board games but is more flexible and adaptable - i.e., general.

I'm an AGI skeptic myself, but I do think that's the best attempt at a formalism for ranking AGI attempts that I've seen so far (disclaimer: as a skeptic I haven't exactly done a deep dive into the field).

Re:John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general int... by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 14, 2019 @03:28AM (#21533774)
> Nothing about what you just described is general.

But once you start integrating over many environments, it seems to make more sense, and the "generality" would be with respect to the set of environments being considered.

Re:John Carmack: I’m going to work on artificial general int... by rapnie on Thursday November 14, 2019 @04:26AM (#21534062)
You'd be correct if the electorate held only one voter: the chessboard environment. But in any other environment the chess bot would fail miserably, no votes gained, whereas a future AGI would score well 'across the board' in many/most environments, win the election.