News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by PaulHoule on Friday January 28, 2011 @01:51PM (#2153001)
Part of the problem with "spammy" content coming out on top is often the competition from real content is pretty thin.

To take the example of Pandora jewelery, Pandora is a company that controls it's marketing channels with an iron fist. They're very careful to partner with better-than-average jewelers and each retailer has an exclusive territory. So far as I know, there's no legitimate channel for new Pandora products online (everybody who claims to sell them on Ebay seems to have fewer than 10 feedbacks.)

Thus, other than Pandora's official website there's no legitimate e-commerce presence for Pandora online, so there's nothing to compete with the junk. Somebody might randomly write about them, but there's nobody (legitimate) who's got a feedback loop going where revenue supports content creation and marketing efforts -- which will inevitable come out on top against amateur competition.

Demand Media, ExpertsExchange and quite a few junk sites similarly thrive on the lack of good content. I was having trouble changing the ribbon on an old typewriter a few weeks ago, and web searches asking about this particular model turned up junk pages with advice like:

(1) Buy a new typewriter ribbon, (2) Take the old typewriter ribbon out, (3) Put the new typewritter ribbon out

Now, these pages were keyword stuffed with the name of the typewriter, but they didn't even bother to have an affiliate (or other) link to a place where I could buy the goddamn typewriter ribbon, which according to them is 33% of the work!

Once more, the feedback loop doesn't exist to nourish a good answer here, so of course the blight is going to move in.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by barrkel on Friday January 28, 2011 @02:38PM (#2153199)
To reinforce the feedback angle, I think it's important to point out that the weeds starve out the opportunity for genuine content to grow into a valuable audience. Even when there's real content that wants to compete, the risk is the upfront investment required to peek out above all the crap exceeds the profit from serving that niche.
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by gojomo on Friday January 28, 2011 @03:29PM (#2153393)
[negative allelopathy]

And, in those cases where the content mills do have a few morsels of useful information, they've usually just pushed other less professionally/cynically optimized sources for the same info down off the first page of results.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by PaulHoule on Friday January 28, 2011 @02:43PM (#2153223)
you bet
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by barista on Friday January 28, 2011 @11:37PM (#2154643)
That's why sometimes I think sites that do manual culling like Quora are greatly valuable. Sure when they have sizeable information, peole will try to spam it too but that spam will soon get cleaned up. Just like wikipedia.
Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by joe_the_user on Friday January 28, 2011 @04:29PM (#2153607)
I think you've hit the nail on the head.

This complaint seems to come from the recent attitude absolutely everything is on the web. But tightly controlled products inherently don't have much web presence since their producers like control and all the search terms in the article seemed to involve terms pointing to these.

"NFL Jersey" - That sounds like "spam bait" already. Lots of (rather unsophisticated) people want these and the NFL itself controls its authorized products.

If you tried "cheap viagra", your results wouldn't be encouraging.

Sorry if the Interwebs are not meeting your expectations...

Perhaps Google should rate the quality of its own searches... That idea is serious.

Re:How Organized Spam is Taking Control of Google's Search R... by coliveira on Friday January 28, 2011 @06:06PM (#2153875)
Well, the genie is out of the bottle, because Google created that market. If you type a question, Google will find an answer. If nobody is interested in the problem, spammers will give you something.