News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by mcrad on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @05:51PM (#21519111)
Hate is a strong word - perhaps these voters you speak of simply don't feel there is a very strong correlation between amount of taxes/fees paid, and services rendered.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by roenxi on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @06:41PM (#21519485)
'Tax' is a simple word for a simple concept that spirals into a very complicated topic in practice. Through taxes the pacifist supports wars, the environmentalist industrialisation, the bigot equality and the individualist collectivism, the staunch right winger the salaries of the leftist politicians, etc, etc.

Hating on the general concept of taxes isn't very productive but people are quite unhappy about the details. Politics involves painful compromises and tax is one of the pointy ends of politics.

I'd hazard that taxes are usually raised to force people to support ideas that the individual taxpayers vehemently oppose - because otherwise presumably said taxpayer would already be paying for the service.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by krageon on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @05:07AM (#21522563)
Your thoughts about why taxes are usually raised are opinionated and don't really offer anything of interest in terms of logical foundation. Your hypothesis that things that people want are already paid for of their own volition conveniently forgets the fact that running a country is not the core competency of the people paying the tax. Thus, they are almost guaranteed to not know what to pay for. They will also not pay for things they do not yet know they need.

All of the competency arguments aside, this smacks of a "the free market will solve it" argument. These arguments are tiresome because the one example raised for the best evidence of this is the US, which is to all the rest of the world (and more than probably some of it's inhabitants) a policy tire fire.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by roenxi on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @05:33AM (#21522675)
> running a country is not the core competency of the people paying the tax

People don't generally pay for things that are in their core competencies. A very common reason to pay someone else to do something is because the person with money doesn't know how to get the result they want.

> the US, which is to all the rest of the world (and more than probably some of it's inhabitants) a policy tire fire.

You might want to pass that on to the migrants of the world. Judging by total migration the United States are possibly most attractive destination available. Its migration intake isn't shabby when looked at as a rate either. That dumpster fire is a powerful attractor.

And even then you've missed the argument. I didn't say taxes were a bad thing. I said that people often have very strong principled objections to what their taxes are used for.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by krageon on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @07:47AM (#21523423)
What I was responding to was:

> taxes are usually raised to force people to support ideas that the individual taxpayers vehemently oppose

This is wrong, because they are raised to support a country and most of that (hence the "usual" qualifier) is to support things people might not know they need. Your response to this is apparently that people do pay for things they don't know they need (or don't understand are necessary), but you fail to tell the reader why. Instead you reiterate that you are convinced they'll definitely pay for them.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by roenxi on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @04:35PM (#21529857)
So people can't be trusted to know what they need personally, but when they vote they suddenly develop a keen understanding of which politicians can offer them the things they don't know they want?

That point isn't reasonable. There can't be a division where people know what they want when they vote but not when they spend money. I suppose there could be in theory, but a system that encourages that that would generally be called 'corrupt government' and the actors involved 'lying politicians' where the people who get voted in do things that the individual voters vehemently oppose.

Voting someone in to office is a broadly similar decision to going out and buying something. Individuals in their capacity as voters are not that different from individuals in their capacity as buyers.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by krageon on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:00AM (#21534468)
I think it is much easier to recognise that someone else is better equipped to make certain domain-specific choices for you and also that they agree in broad strokes with how you think than it is to learn that entire domain and make the right funding choices. In my experience that is true for most people, but of course it might not be true for you! Thankfully we live in a world where what is good for most people is leading, and not just what is true for you.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by erikpukinskis on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:39PM (#21519935)
> taxes are usually raised to force people to support....

Sorry, the first half of your sentence is too broad for the rest of it to possibly be true.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by roenxi on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @08:28PM (#21520296)
Honestly I'm not sure your comment is any more helpful to me than just leaving a down vote. You havn't explained what you mean, there isn't an argument and I'm at a loss trying to follow your complaint. I could see that applying to the other part of the sentence - "ideas that the individual taxpayers vehemently oppose" - but the bit you've picked out is just literally true. Taxes are levied to finance schemes whether the taxpayer agrees with them or not.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by erikpukinskis on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @01:13PM (#21527372)
Sorry, didn’t mean to be obtuse.

Logically speaking, the assertion that 50%+ of taxes are driven by the same motivation seems impossible. Taxation is such a generic mechanism at work in so many different places, your assertion seems like a non-starter to me.

Did you intend to make such a strong claim?

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by roenxi on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @04:27PM (#21529779)
That I can learn from. Thanks :)

The intent was quite different, I didn't see a reading of that sentence that involved motivation but now that it has been pointed out I can see that it is the most obvious one. My intent was more about the outcomes of a tax but that wasn't expressed.

What I wanted to say was something more like "No political decision has perfect support, and many cause stark divisions. But taxpayers financially support all the decisions taken and they will be vehemently opposed to some of the things they fund".

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by stretchwithme on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @05:57PM (#21519160)
And many who talk about how we should gladly pay our taxes get or figure they would get more than they pay in if everybody would happily pay as much as they possibly could.

Not that the amount of taxes paid ever stopped a government from trying borrow and spend way more than that.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:28PM (#21519841)
Governments don't "borrow and spend". Money is a political abstraction, not a tangible one. It is physically impossible for a government to run out of fiat money.

The only things a government can run out of are faith in the future and internal and external trust. When either or both of those disappear, human animals panic and the economy stops working.

Private enclosure of capital - which is equivalent to private enclosure of political and economic power - is far more likely to create that sort of breakdown than high taxes and generous public spending. (Effective - non-corrupt - public spending being equivalent to policy decisions that broaden and diffuse political power rather than concentrating it.)

Effective generous public spending is actually a political negative feedback mechanism that damps wild oscillations in confidence, seeds future investment, and enhances political stability.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by stretchwithme on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @10:55PM (#21521049)
I think you're confusing money with resources. Money is a medium of exchange. The resources are real.

Governments frequently consume more resources than they can purchase with the taxes they collect.

Yes, they could just print all the money they could ever need. And when they do, inflation runs wild. Then a government cannot borrow in its own currency because no one will trust it. Or it must pay a high rate.

The US government is in a unique situation. It's been able to print much more than a government normally could because it is the most trusted reserve currency in a rapidly globalizing world. Trillions of dollars are held overseas. And if the dollar loses that role, you will see a lot of inflation as those dollars return to the US. Even if it doesn't lose that role and the world just stops taking additional dollars, the US would have to print less to keep the same rate of inflation.

Most governments don't fall into this category. And no country is in this category forever.

A country's currency is really just another form of debt. And while it may never run out, the more it prints, the more it declines in value. It's not debt people can collect on, but the law of supply and demand will certainly collect on this debt.

And it's also a tax, a tax on savings. And the country could remove dollars from circulation, thereby reducing this debt and reversing the decline in the value of savings.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by duahncjak on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @11:22PM (#21521150)
Countries have held much higher debt levels than the US currently does without being the global reserve currency.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by stretchwithme on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @02:28AM (#21521814)
How much currency a country prints and how much it borrows are two different things.
Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by tabtab on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @09:23PM (#21520642)
In practice the gov't has to pretend like the money is real in order to prevent chaos. In fact both gov't and citizens have to pretend "properly" for it to work. It's a mutual agreement about how to represent the value of commerce.

Laws are the same way: members of civilization have to mutually agree on how to create and follow the laws for them to "work".

Civilization is the Mother of All Handshakes. If a large enough percentage of the population disagrees with the "agreements", anarchy happens.

Modern technology and civilization are both inherently driven by standards: both written and de-facto.

Re:Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup by tabtab on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @06:47PM (#21519520)
Re: Not that the amount of taxes paid ever stopped a government from trying borrow and spend way more than that.

Government, taxes, and private industry are all tools of civilization. Tools are imperfect and the human managers & users are imperfect. One has to monitor all of them to keep them in decent working order. They won't just automatically run in an optimum mode if citizens don't keep a critical eye on them all.