Re:Poll: Should the US President have an Internet kill-switch?
by Cushman on Thursday January 27, 2011 @10:55PM
(#2150730)
It's an open question, certainly, but the broad meaning isn't vague. It's anything that would legally or technologically enable the Executive branch to disable public internet access in all or part of the United States at will.
I can't think up a way to make that a plausibly good thing to exist in any form.
Re:Poll: Should the US President have an Internet kill-switch?
by Locke1689 on Friday January 28, 2011 @12:07AM
(#2150870)
Then explain to me how this could not exist. As long as there are routable ASes they can be shut down.
Re:Poll: Should the US President have an Internet kill-switch?
by abhimishra on Thursday January 27, 2011 @11:18PM
(#2150779)
I don't even think it needs to be a switch. The actual bill that was brought up in the Senate doesn't explicitly say 'kill switch' anywhere. In reality a call from someone in the government to a few people who work at large ISPs/backbones would be enough, since they would just comply. We saw this happen recently with Wikileaks, after all....
Re:Poll: Should the US President have an Internet kill-switch?
by kbyers on Friday January 28, 2011 @01:07AM
(#2150983)
It is not so easy--large networks will have a lot of redundancy built-in. Consequently, even shutting down a single large BGP autonomous system is not a simple problem and would have a lot of unintended consequences.
Wikileaks is not a good analogy. Wikileaks is more analogous to black-holing one small AS.
Re:Poll: Should the US President have an Internet kill-switch?
by solipsist on Thursday January 27, 2011 @11:34PM
(#2150814)
> Stupid question.
Don't you think that's a little harsh to say, if not even disrespectful. As quoted from the Hacker News Guidelines (that I'm sure you must have read before):
When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.
E.g. "That is an idiotic thing to say; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened
to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
This remarks adds nothing to your point and rather discredits your opinion for many of us.> I think this question doesn't really have an answer because it's too poorly defined.
This is fair to say, but I left it broad for a reason - hoping people would debate the general principle rather than specific details. If the broadness of the poll is too much for you, then ignore it.
I think this question doesn't really have an answer because it's too poorly defined.