News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data

Here's my conspiracy theory: Google wrote a script to export data from "deleted" Fitbit user accounts, but forgot to disable functionality linked to the related auto-emails.

Timetable:

11/1/19 @ 11:14am: Received "Confirm your Fitbit data export request" email (I requested this export manually)

11/1/19 @ 11:23am: Received "Your export has begun" email (after I logged in and confirmed)

11/1/19 @ 11:58am: Received "Your export has completed" email

11/1/19 @ 1:16pm: Immediately after deleting my Fitbit account, received a confirmation email stating: After 7 days: Your account is frozen and can't be recovered

-------------------------------------------

11/11/19 @ 10:38am: Received "Confirm your Fitbit data export request" email (I did not make this request, and can't even log into Fitbit)

11/11/19 @ 10:38am: Received "Your export has begun" email

11/11/19 @ 10:38am: Received "Your export has completed" email

( 5 comments | 12 points | on HN )
Re:I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data by londons_explore on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:19PM (#21506612)
Check the message id's to see if it is in fact the same email you are seeing again.

Also check any id's in the URL for differences - if there is no difference in the confirmation code, then it's an old email being resent, possibly because some mail server on the route didn't correctly ACK your message.

Re:I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data by jb775 on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:39PM (#21506824)
The URL id's are different, I don't see any message id's.
Re:I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data by natdempk on Monday November 11, 2019 @11:19PM (#21511483)
In your mail client if you hit "Show original message" or "View message source" or something similar you should be able to see a Message-ID header on the raw MIME email message itself.
Re:I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data by swtrs on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @08:12AM (#21513761)
Apparently lots of people did over on r/fitbit : https://www.reddit.com/r/fitbit/comments/duu705/was_fitbit_j...
Re:I think Google just hoarded my “deleted” Fitbit data by username90 on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:27PM (#21509090)
Alternatively the bug is that the final script to delete the data also sends the same emails.