Just because you do this doesn't mean it makes sense for everyone. Allowing Google more access because it gives more reward makes perfect business sense. Why should anyone and everyone be allowed to crawl and scrape my website or nobody allowed? The world isn't a series of black and white decisions.
I'm not saying you were in the wrong, but that is the stance I would (and do, with my current project) take. And of course, when we are ready, we will open the door to all indexing.