That no one else has that right maybe tells us we should expand CCW reciprocity. It's already something like 35 states.
I'd need to see some stats on how often retited police officers are retaliated against by criminals before I'll buy that this is anywhere near likely enough to worry about.
How many retired law enforcement officers go on binge shooting sprees?
Or should we oppose them having a legally purchased firearm just because?
The double standard!
Either way assuming that being armed doesn't provide a 100% effective deterrent, statistics should still help us here. Even assuming a very high deterrence rate, you would still expect to see at least a handful of revenge murders of retired cops every year if this was a significant problem at all.
>provides no defense advantage should they do so
This one should be very easy to determine. How many times each year do armed retired cops thwart revenge attacks?
From what a quick Google search tells me both of these things basically never happen.
If not, how are these police privileges remotely relevant to any need beyond that of a normal citizen?