News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by noobermin on Sunday November 10, 2019 @03:23PM (#21499962)
Should developers be paid by the lines of code they produce?
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Nasrudith on Sunday November 10, 2019 @07:14PM (#21501131)
If lines of code were a useful commodity in themselves? Yes it would be reasonable. Now we know that is not the case and any attempt to do so would ens in foregone disaster.

The reason not to do things like that is if said metrics can do more harm than good. However freight is pretty commodity by definition. Aside from not doing damage to goods and people, throughput is basically the only things that matter in that context.

Employees demanding a "standby base rate" would also be sensible if they were required to wait while lacking work to do.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by noobermin on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:39AM (#21504720)
What about by files of code they produce? Or webpages or assets? I imagine some contractors work this way.

Why can't what developers produce be commodified?

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Thriptic on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:00PM (#21500443)
Should developers keep their job if they fail to deliver every sprint and miss deadlines? At the end of the day we are all judged by output; it just so happens that output is more easily measured in trucking (ie the status is binary) than in development.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by ta0987 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:49PM (#21500691)
People are paid based on what they have the leverage to demand, not based on what's right or wrong.

Regulated taxi fare formulas usually include both time and distance. A mile in a traffic jam will be based on time. Ten miles with no traffic will be based on distance. Why should truckers not get paid for sitting in a traffic jam if cabbies do? It still costs the trucker time that he can't be doing/working something/somewhere else.

Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Thriptic on Sunday November 10, 2019 @06:14PM (#21500814)
Because then they might take excessively long breaks and get paid for not working. It would be extremely difficult to audit time spent working while being plagued by inefficiencies vs time spent messing around. Paying per delivery aligns incentives and is easy to audit. It also incentivizes truckers to push on dock workers to be more efficient which is in the entire supply chain's best interest.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by noobermin on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:15AM (#21504940)
You can make the same argument against paying developers a salary. Ditto on paying managers a salary.
Re:As L.A. ports automate, some workers are cheering on the ... by Thriptic on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:24AM (#21505529)
Yes you could which is why you have contractors. However, it turns out that with "creative" work it's a lot harder to implement that payment model without having an incentives problem.