News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by coldtea on Sunday November 10, 2019 @03:13PM (#21499902)
A decision not to release a feature (AirDrop) on older machines, is taken as an example of Planned Obsolescence.

Sorry, that's not what planned obsolescence means.

The machine wasn't made to be less capable over time for what it was originally sold for. Features (software or hardware) weren't decided to suddenly break.

It would just not get some new features in future OS even if it could (which is debatable). It might could (according to the dev) but give a subpar experience, or eat into the battery, etc. One can say "that should be for the user to decide" but that's not how Apple works, nor has ever been part of their value proposition. Their value proposition is "we think of most of those things for you". In the end, even if the older machines could support the feature just fine, not releasing it for them is standard practice to entice people to a new model, and has nothing to do with "planned obsolescence".

If anything Apple has a great track record on both:

1) Getting new iOS releases to older machines. Most Android vendors were horrible at that, abandoning machines even at the first release after being sold.

2) Having machines (including iPhones) keep their resale value high. That's the opposite of planned obsolescence.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by microtherion on Sunday November 10, 2019 @06:05PM (#21500772)
> A decision not to release a feature (AirDrop) on older machines, is taken as an example of Planned Obsolescence.

And of course, if Apple DOES release a feature for an older machine for which it's borderline performant, it gets accused of… planned obsolescence.

Can't win with some people.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by kirb on Monday November 11, 2019 @03:47AM (#21503108)
Yep, the prerequisite for AirDrop, Handoff, SMS/voice call relay to your iPhone, etc. was a Bluetooth 4.0-capable wireless chipset. You could actually purchase an upgraded wireless module from 3rd-party sellers on Aliexpress/Amazon/eBay for <$100 and install it in an older MacBook with a Philips screwdriver. Apple made no money in that transaction, and you got to have one of the “killer features” of the latest Macs for a great price.

A better argument for planned obsolescence might be that Apple discontinued this modular design in the current MacBooks and integrated the wireless chipset onto the main logic board, making such an upgrade impossible in future if a new feature has a dependency on more recent wireless hardware.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by FireBeyond on Sunday November 10, 2019 @03:54PM (#21500133)
This is some double speak.

> not releasing it for them is standard practice to entice people to a new model, and has nothing to do with "planned obsolescence".

That's literally exactly what it is.

"You could have that, but because we've thought it better for you that you don't have it, but if you get newer hardware you could have it". It's obsolete, because it's artificially not compatible with current feature sets.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by coldtea on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:06PM (#21500204)
>That's literally exactly what it is.

Not really. Not getting new features doesn't make an existing product worse.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by FireBeyond on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:23PM (#21500285)
It does when it arbitrarily reduces interoperability with current products. Even more so when it's done to "entice new product purchase".

Beside that, using your definition of "products getting worse" would make the whole concept of planned obsolesce almost a minuscule sliver of any issue with any product.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by coldtea on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:58AM (#21502960)
>It does when it arbitrarily reduces interoperability with current products. Even more so when it's done to "entice new product purchase".

Who promised "interoperability with current products" in new features?

>Beside that, using your definition of "products getting worse" would make the whole concept of planned obsolesce almost a minuscule sliver of any issue with any product.

Actually it's a huge domain just at that, and that was the original understading of the concept: "in industrial design and economics is a policy of planning or designing a product with an artificially limited useful life, so that it becomes obsolete (i.e., unfashionable, or no longer functional) after a certain period of time."

Notice "industrial design" -- which was what the term was coined for.

It wasn't about a Generation N device not getting Generation + 1 device features (which at the time, for mechanical devices, it couldn't).

It was things like promoting plastic throw-away razors (as opposed to multi-use ones), device parts that last N years where they could easily last xN, and so on...

If we're talking Apple, glueing things to the motherboard and not letting access to upgrade parts is the real planned obsolescence by the canonical understanding.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by WalterGR on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:03AM (#21502278)
I'm curious where your rigid definition of the term "planned obsolescence" originates. The Wikipedia page, for example, presents a few alternative takes.

"Systemic obsolescence" seems to fit, if you consider the ecosystem as the system.

But there's no real sense in quibbling over the precise definition. What would you term the arbitrary and capricious decision to not support a new feature on a perfectly capable platform?

What if I were releasing a succession of new laptops, and I said to my employees, "As we release new software that runs on these laptops, we'll actively, needlessly disable new software features on laptop models over 5 years old"? Since technology and software moves on, it seems to me like that's planning which makes a product obsolete.

Re:Apple Products and Planned Obsolescence by coldtea on Monday November 11, 2019 @03:03AM (#21502975)
>But there's no real sense in quibbling over the precise definition. What would you term the arbitrary and capricious decision to not support a new feature on a perfectly capable platform?

Basic product differentiation, for one.