News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by BurningFrog on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:31AM (#21498327)
The counterintuitive solution is to get rid of campaign finance restrictions.

If money is easier to get, candidates will need to "pay" less for it in favors.

To understand the dynamics here, the key fact is that additional money only helps a campaign up until it has enough to get its message to the voters. More money after that doesn't impact the result.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by lostmyoldone on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:08AM (#21498518)
Political parties and their representatives stopped trying to only get their message to voters a long time ago. Today they want to target - and preferably close to drown - each person with the sequence of messages, video clips, social media reactions, and sound bites that are most likely to get you to vote for them, based on as much data as possible, and oftentimes both using and abusing every cognitive weakness we humans tend to have.

This is almost indistinguishable from what used to be called propaganda, and generally seen as somewhat problematic even before it was inundated with individual targeting and the ungodly amount of realpolitik we see today.

This is not a game where there is ever enough money, and it can work terrifyingly good, almost no matter what agenda you push, as long as the agenda is all that you care about.

Sure it might come tumbling down one day, if the lies becomes to obvious. The damage will still have been done at that point.

If history has taught us anything, it seem to be more of the opposite of what you claim.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by BurningFrog on Sunday November 10, 2019 @02:11PM (#21499571)
That's your personal analysis.

What I said wasn't my opinion, it's the consensus from the research that's been done on this.

Anyone who lived through the 2010 California governors race could also see Brown being outspent 5:1, and win easily.

There is a correlation/causation illusion here: The (A) winner in votes usually also has the (B) biggest donation to the campaign. Can you see the two main reasons why A causes B, and not the reverse?

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by wpskidd on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:38AM (#21498363)
How about we instead consider distancing the human political actors from direct contact with temptation? Corruption is an integral part of all political systems and ultimately festers until inevitable failure and restart. Can’t we start to consider open source, programmatic execution of popularly derived decisions?
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by DayDollar on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:46AM (#21498410)
I have quite the oppossite approach- if corruption is so unavoidable, why not instituionalize it? The economic sector gets 25 % of the votes in parliament. Companys can boost the percentage of there representive in this fixed part, by paying taxes (in secret). If there are 25 company representives, and every company pays 1 billion - they get each get 1% of the economic-sector-power to distribute.

Corruption outside of this fixed percentage is heavy penalized, as in life prison sentences.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by thingification on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:19AM (#21498585)
If we know that corruption varies a lot between states (as in countries) and, worldwide, has reduced over time, why would we think it's inevitable?

I see a lot of estimating-as-inevitable in many problem areas - for example: the environment, race and sex relations, security / "privacy". I'm not sure whether it has increased, or I'm just more aware of it these days.

When we think that a problem is inevitable, we may conclude that various reponses that otherwise have little to recommend them might be a good thing: populisms, zero-sum thinking, authoritarianism, radical transparency. This idea of inevitability is in conflict with optimism in David Deutsch's sense: optimism as the principle that all problems are caused by lack of knowledge (and therefore that all problems are either solvable, or truly inevitable because of some law of physics - no examples of the latter being known).

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by DayDollar on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:50AM (#21606638)
No trying to be optimistic here- but the fact is that with the nightwatch state- alot of corruption simply ceased to be because the rule of law evaporated- making corruption effectively legal behaviour. Germany, the place where i live is incredible corrupt, but most of it is legal behaviour, thus not showing up in your statistics.
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by wool_gather on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:21PM (#21498954)
Nothing in your scheme prevents corruption outside its designated lines any more than what we have already. So I have a counter-proposal: why don't we just skip the legitimization step and move straight to the life sentences?
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by DayDollar on Sunday November 10, 2019 @02:01PM (#21499522)
Its basically a free market for power- and in a market for power, nobody trust one another- so game theory tells us, everyone will try to make secret agreements, and then go all in to get the most out of it.

And if all that lobbying money piled up , goes into the organized corruption, there is little left for the rest of the power percentage.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by mattkrause on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:35AM (#21498356)
Aren't we trying that already? Citizens United dramatically loosened the rules on campaign finance.
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by rayiner on Sunday November 10, 2019 @10:53AM (#21498434)
Citizens United had nothing to do with campaign finance. It was about election-related speech by an independent third-party non-profit organization.
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by js2 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:03AM (#21498491)
The term "campaign finance" appears on this page 45 times:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC

Maybe you could say "technically, the case invalidated restrictions on campaign related advertising by third parties, so-called soft money. Though this may be commonly referred to as campaign finance, strictly speaking, that's not correct." I think very few non-lawyers would say the case "had nothing to do with" campaign finance.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by rayiner on Sunday November 10, 2019 @11:18AM (#21498577)
The specific provision at issue in Citizens United was part of the campaign finance laws for the same reason the Patriot Act is called what it is. But it had nothing to do with financing of campaigns. It involved speech prohibitions on corporations and labor unions unrelated to campaigns.
Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by mattkrause on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:49PM (#21499125)
What?

The issue the heart of Citizens United v. FEC (i.e., the Federal Elections Commission) was whether a non-profit's funding of a TV special criticizing a candidate violated the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act.

I guess it's technically true that the decision doesn't allow more money to flow directly to the campaign, and there's not /supposed/ to be coordination with campaigns either (wink wink, nudge nudge), but it's very obvious that CU increased the flow and role of money in elections.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by rayiner on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:38PM (#21500339)
> The issue the heart of Citizens United v. FEC (i.e., the Federal Elections Commission) was whether a non-profit's funding of a TV special criticizing a candidate violated the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act.

In ordinary parlance, do we say “Apple funds iOS” or do we say “Apple makes iOS?” In Citizens United the non-profit produced and sought to air a movie called Hillary: the Movie. They didn’t “fund” any candidate’s political campaign.

> I guess it's technically true that the decision doesn't allow more money to flow directly to the campaign

By “technically true” you mean “true.” “Campaign finance” laws presumably have to do with financing of campaigns. The “role of money in elections” is a different, much broader area, much of it outside the scope of campaign finance laws. (For example, consider the alleged $5 billion in free advertising the press gave Trump. Do campaign finance laws allow the government to regulate that?)

One can imagine lumping in scenarios where someone is attempting to bypass a campaign finance restriction by directing a third party to produce content for the campaign. But that’s not what Citizens United involved either. There was no allegation of any such “indirect” campaign financing. Instead, the government tried a naked power grab: punishing a non-profit for making a political movie, with no showing of any link to the campaign beyond that.

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by mattkrause on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:39PM (#21500641)
I'm not sure that many people draw the distinction you're trying to make. Kennedy's opinion itself describes the outcome of Citizens United in terms of campaign finance reform:

"A campaign finance system that pairs corporate independent expenditures with effective disclosure has not existed before today." https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/558/310/#tab-opi...

Virtually every bit of media coverage describes it in similar terms too. Still, it was a 5-4 case that produced five opinions, so if that's the hair you want to split, so be it. I think my original comment stands just as well if it's amended to "Aren't we trying that already? Citizens United already dramatically relaxed ELECTION SPENDING rules."

Re:We Should Let a Lottery Decide Our Government by js2 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:44PM (#21500666)
Citizens United v. FEC invalidated laws beyond the specifics of the case. I think your argument is a pedantic one. I'm not a lawyer, but I follow politics more closely than probably 98% of Americans and I've commonly understood Citizens United to be related to what most Americans and the press refer to as "campaign finance", which is more broad than the strict definition you're using.

CU is listed in a Wikipedia section titled "Campaign finance in the United States":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_in_the_United...

To use your own words, in "ordinary parlance" CU is part of campaign finance.