News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go Turns 10 by baby on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:12PM (#21489091)
no metaprogramming is a feature. Have you read C++ libraries?
Re:Go Turns 10 by lasagnaphil on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:05AM (#21490101)
C++'s template metaprogramming was "found" as an accident, and is a very bad example of metaprogramming as a whole. (Techniques like SFINAE and CRTP seem more like a hack, and leaves a bad taste in your mouth when you use it.)

What we should talk about instead: hygienic macros in Scheme/Rust, AST-level modification in Nim, dependent types, etc. I think metaprogramming is an aspect of programming that should be explored more, and is definitely useful for reducing boilerplate.

Re:Go Turns 10 by hechang1997 on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:58PM (#21489275)
C++ template metaprogramming may be overused and very difficult to use, but its prevalence despite such difficulty precisely shows how much such a type level metaprogramming tool is desired (compared to syntax level ones like lisp macros or text level ones like C preprocessor and various code generators). New programming languages should try to improve upon C++ template metaprogramming and make more powerful and effective metaprogramming language constructs, instead of completely abandoning the front.
Re:Go Turns 10 by mantap on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:49PM (#21489692)
This is the putting one's head in the sand methodology of programming lanaguge design.

Go's answer to metaprogramming is source code generation. There are many problems with C++ but the existence of the template system isn't one.

Re:Go Turns 10 by acroback on Saturday November 09, 2019 @09:26AM (#21491716)
For you it isn't. But for a lot of us it is cumbersome and just plain complex.
Re:Go Turns 10 by mantap on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:55AM (#21492593)
The source of complexity is in the problems C++ is designed to solve. I use C++ metaprogramming for problems that require it.

Sure, Boost is full of metaprogramming insanity, but with today's C++ standard library it's not necessary to use Boost.

10 years ago template heavy code in C++ did suck, because we had slow compilers, dumb build systems, 7200 rpm HDDs and a need to use Boost to augment the bare bones standard library.

I'll be the first to admit that C++ has decades of cruft and design errors. But the metaprogramming works pretty well now. C++'s current problems are (IMO) weird undefined behavior, e.g. the distinction between POD and non-POD types; having both pointers and references, the ancient exception system, and in general a lack of tools for enforcing memory safety.