I don’t see the connection to Apple. Apple offers limited choice and little room to optimize. You get what everyone else gets, I can’t imagine “Optimizers” buying Apple products.
Edit: Wouldn’t you buy an Apple product exactly if you are tired of having to compare all the time? All of Apple’s products fit on a decent sized kitchen table (five computers, four music players, two phones, two tablets, one set-top box). Wouldn’t many people who like Apple say that the nice thing about Apple is that you can trust them, that you can blindly buy their products and still be reasonably certain that you are getting a good package? The best Android phones might well be better than the iPhone but you actually have to find them in a sea of many phones of wildly differing quality.
http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2010/06/25/77-of-iphone-4-sales-...
Since there's not much of an upgrade path for Android devices in quite the same way I suspect finding numbers to compare against will be hard. Besides, the platform didn't start to really become popular until 2009-ish, so most people are still on their first Android phone.
When a new major Android phone is launched, there's no line, but it takes weeks on a waiting list to get one and months for the inventory to catch back up so you can just go buy one.
I have a feeling one of the two (or both) is either a manifestation of what we're talking about, or its Nintendo style artificial scarcity at play.
Internet search is your friend
(try to avoid the word Google in connection with friend ;o)
My MacBook does everything I need, and it has the Unix underpinnings I prefer. My iPhone is very useful, although it is getting a little slow as apps get bigger. I will probably upgrade to the iPhone 5 when it comes out, if it turns out to be good enough.
I'm the same way with cars. I bought a Honda Civic recently without a lot of comparison shopping because I have had good luck with them before, and I know it's a quality car. A friend of mine bought another kind of car that had some cool features that mine doesn't have, and I was a little envious for a moment, but it soon passed. I'm very happy with my solid little car.
On the other hand, the good enough types make a quick decision and don't look back - or, spend sufficient time to find what they need and then don't look back.
I think it depends on your personal preferences (or on the amount of time you have available).
Who wants to spend time on the choice of a dumb phone? I certainly don't and I have better things to do. I am a user of the first 5GB iPod. It was a gorgeous tool but today I am glad that I don't have to carry this brick with me anymore. That's why I never considered an iPhone or an Android thing so far.
But, if you like, go ahead.