News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by perfunctory on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:42AM (#21474149)
Do you plan any moderation to combat climate deniers?
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by briandear on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:10PM (#21475654)
Why would we want to “combat” different opinions? Contrarian opinions are healthy. Dogma should always be challenged — if anything, such challenges help people better define and strengthen their own arguments. Most of us “deniers” don’t deny climate change, we just disagree with the causes and the proposed solutions. Science isn’t static, data isn’t always conclusive and outside agendas aren’t always disclosed.
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by ericvanular on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:29PM (#21475862)
You've eloquently stated my position in better words than I had used. Thank you, please feel free to chip in these thoughts on the platform
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by joshypants on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:33PM (#21476502)
Wow, this doesn't instill confidence in your moderation abilities. You need to show people who "disagree on the causes" the door.
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by ericvanular on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:42PM (#21476571)
Conversely, I think that heavy censorship of opposing ideas shows a lack of confidence in one's own opinion. If we can't debate effectively the merits of climate action in a community designed for it, then we need to work on our messaging
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by joshypants on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:31PM (#21477522)
you're going to let a bunch of astroturfing people wreck your platform and it's not going to be useful to anyone. you're being naive.
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by ericvanular on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:49AM (#21474207)
We have baked-in anti spam moderation to the community. In regards to climate deniers coming on and brigading the community, I felt that it would be better to let moderators & the community treat those on a case by case basis with counter arguments and voting as necessary

What do you think? I'm open to suggestion but I feel like suppressing free speech goes against the ideals of the community

Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by vcdimension on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:47PM (#21476629)
Absolutely agree with that, but the problem might be people not having the time to follow up on long discussions, and source information to disprove climate denier arguments. In fact my experience is that many climate activists are not that familiar with the science & economics themselves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8qaJKM77j00 (she should have quoted Martin Weitzman's work on the fat tails of the climate sensitivity distribution).

I would suggest having a repository of clear arguments and counter arguments with links to reputable scientific sources, that we can refer any climate deniers to. For example: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2018/06/will-c...

Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by ericvanular on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:34PM (#21477539)
I'm hearing you loud and clear. That's a great idea to keep the conversation focused. If you're willing, we would love to have you put forward this idea on the platform itself!
Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by perfunctory on Thursday November 07, 2019 @03:23PM (#21476918)
I am just worried that your platform might turn into a debate forum with endless back and forth arguments instead of being a "community for discussing positive climate actions". Discussing actions assumes you already agree on what the problem is. If you want to be successful, focus is the key. And to enable focus, you need to guard your community. Heck, HN is successful and heavily moderated.

edit: If you are serious about solving climate crisis, there is no time for counter arguments. Arguing with deniers and "sceptics" is a distraction and a waist of time. They are already a minority anyway. The majority of the population, both in US and EU, supports climate policies. The task is not to convert sceptics, the task now is to get the pro climate majority off their butts, away from their keyboards, and to "the streets".

Re:Show HN: Collective.Energy – Crowdsource climate solution... by ericvanular on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:35PM (#21477554)
Very valid concern. Thanks for your feedback! I'd suggest that you post that on the community Meta section and we can determine a standard approach for dealing with climate deniers transparently out in the open. What do you think?