News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:15AM (#21473880)
Have you ever heard of Esterel or Céu? They follow the synchronous concurrency paradigm, which apparently has specific trade-offs that give it great advantages on embedded (IIRC the memory overhead per Céu "trail" is much lower than for async threads (in the order of bytes), fibers or whatnot, but computationally it scales worse with the nr of trails).

Céu is the more recent one of the two and is a research language that was designed with embedded systems in mind, with the PhD theses to show for it [2][3].

I wish other languages would adopt ideas from Céu. I have a feeling that if there was a language that supports both kinds of concurrency and allows for the GALS approach (globally asynchronous (meaning threads in this context), locally synchronous) you would have something really powerful on your hands.

EDIT: Er... sorry, this may have been a bit of an inappropriate comment, shifting the focus away from the Rust celebration. I'm really happy for Rust for finally landing this! (but could you pretty please start experimenting with synchronous concurrency too? ;) )

[0] http://ceu-lang.org/

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Esterel

[2] http://ceu-lang.org/chico/ceu_phd.pdf

[3] http://sunsite.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/Publications/AIB/20...

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by kbenson on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:46PM (#21477646)
> Er... sorry, this may have been a bit of an inappropriate comment, shifting the focus away from the Rust celebration.

I think if it's interesting and spurs useful conversation, it's appropriate, tangent or not. I for one an thankful for your suggested links, they look interesting.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by Rusky on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:28AM (#21474611)
It's not the same, but Rust async/await tasks are also in the order of bytes, and you can get similar "structured concurrency"-like control flow with things like `futures::join!` or `futures::select!`.

Ceu looks very neat, I suspect (having not read much about it yet) that async codebases could take a lot of inspiration from it already.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:55AM (#21474880)
> you can get similar "structured concurrency"-like control flow with things like `futures::join!` or `futures::select!`.

That sounds very promising, I should give it a closer look (I don't program in Rust myself so I only read blogs out of intellectual curiosity)

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by naasking on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:30PM (#21475192)
Or you can use something like protothreads or async.h [1] if you're stuck with C/C++ and need something lightweight.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21033496

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:03AM (#21480084)
Céu compiles to C actually, and I believe Francisco Sant’Anna (the author of the language) makes a direct comparison to protothreads and nesC in one of his papers (probably the PhD thesis). I had not seen async.h before though, interesting!

[1] http://ceu-lang.org/publications.html

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by mamcx on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:45AM (#21474169)
I also think async (the paradigm) is kind of weird in rust world. I agree with https://journal.stuffwithstuff.com/2015/02/01/what-color-is-....
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by pcwalton on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:31AM (#21474654)
The solution suggested by that article is to use M:N threading, which was tried in Rust and turned out to be slower than plain old 1:1 threading.

If you don't want to deal with async functions, then you can use threads! That's what they're there for. On Linux they're quite fast. Async is for when you need more performance than what 1:1 or M:N threading can provide.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by mamcx on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:51AM (#21474841)
> If you don't want to deal with async functions, then you can use threads!

Truly? If some very popular lib become async (like actix, request, that I use), I can TRULY ignore it and not split my world in async/sync?

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by pcwalton on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:05PM (#21474968)
You can easily convert async to sync by just blocking on the result. The other way (sync to async) is more difficult and requires proxying out to a thread pool, but it's also doable.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by BatmanAoD on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:00PM (#21507718)
An `async` function _can_ call blocking functions, of course, it just blocks the entire thread of execution which could otherwise continue making progress by polling another future.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by nemothekid on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:25PM (#21475148)
Both actix and reqwest are already async, the fact that you haven't noticed yet just shows that you are already ignoring it.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by mamcx on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:56PM (#21475491)
But the signatures are not. If them mark the types/functions async, what happened?

I must rewrite all the calls?

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by pas on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:19PM (#21475747)
Async is just a syntactic sugar for Future<...>, you can poll() it manually.

You can take the event loop, run it on one thread and do whatever you wish on other threads.

Fearless concurrency, after all.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by bluejekyll on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:53PM (#21476107)
you can just `.await` on any Future returned directly by APIs, if it's not marked as an async fn.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by tomp on Friday November 08, 2019 @04:10AM (#21480863)
How hard was it tried?

I imagine there's a reason that languages like Go adopted M:N threading... obviously part of the reason is that it's way more scaleable, but userspace threading is also supposed to be faster, as context switches don't need to switch to kernel space... were the problems tight loops (which AFAIK is also the problem in Go)? or maybe it's just so much easier / more efficient if you also have GC...

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by dunkelheit on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:36AM (#21481663)
In my opinion they tried hard enough. Here are the links to the discussions of that time if you are into that kind of thing:

https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/rust-dev/2013-November/00...

https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/rust-dev/2013-November/00...

https://github.com/rust-lang/rfcs/blob/master/text/0230-remo...

It is clear that they really wanted to make green threading work, but in the end it proved incompatible with other goals of the language.

The main problem as I understand it is with the stack: you can't make the stack big from the beginning (or your threads wouldn't be lightweight anymore) so you need to grow it dynamically. If you grow it by adding new segments to the linked list, you get the "stack thrashing"/"hot split" problem: if you are unlucky and have to allocate/deallocate a segment in a tight loop the performance suffers horribly. Go solved the problem by switching to contiguous relocatable stacks: if there is not enough space in the stack, a bigger contiguous chunk of memory is allocated and old contents of the stack are copied there (a-la C++ vector). Now there is a problem with references to the stack-allocated variables - they become invalid. In go this problem is solvable because it is a managed garbage-collected language so they can simply rewrite all the references to point to the new locations but in rust it is infeasible.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by the_why_of_y on Friday November 08, 2019 @05:53AM (#21481210)
The reason is that M:N threading inherently requires a language runtime, and the advantage of increased scalability (GHC threads use less than 1KB of memory) comes with the disadvantage that FFI calls are really quite expensive to do, because you need to move to a separate native thread in case the FFI call blocks.

These languages (Erlang, Haskell, Go, ...) have no ambition to be useful for system programming; they're not intended as a replacement for C/C++ in that domain, unlike Rust.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by danShumway on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:03PM (#21475573)
Author's solution is threads:

> But if you have threads (green- or OS-level), you don’t need to do that. You can just suspend the entire thread and hop straight back to the OS or event loop without having to return from all of those functions.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't the lack of threads one of the biggest reasons why NodeJS originally outperformed most of its competitors?

Spinning up threads for each concurrent request was expensive, and (nonblocking) async code was by comparison ridiculously cheap, so the lack of overhead meant Node could just make everything async, instead of trying to decide up-front which tasks deserved which resources.

Granted, it's been over a decade since Node came out. Maybe thread overhead has gotten a lot better? But barring faulty memory, I definitely remember a number of people explaining to me back then that being single-threaded was the point.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by IfOnlyYouKnew on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:22AM (#21481587)
I'm pretty sure that was the official talking point at the time, and some people may have even been motivated enough to actually belief it.

Of course that all changed once Node got threads.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by BatmanAoD on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:07PM (#21507795)
Did it, though? AFAIK Node still doesn't have OS threads, which are the expensive version. The "About" page still says that Node is "designed without threads": https://nodejs.org/en/about/
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:20AM (#21474540)
All 5 of his points seem to be 2015 Javascript only. Some of them don't even apply to modern Javascript; I don't see any that apply to rust.
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:05AM (#21481519)
While I'm happy to believe you, with a short comment like that I just have to take your word for it. Could give a short explanation of how Rust already addresses each of these points for those of us who don't program in it?
Re:Async-await on stable Rust by littlestymaar on Friday November 08, 2019 @09:28AM (#21482426)
This article is 90% a rant against “callback hell” that js was facing before async/await was introduced. The remaining 10% stays valid even in the presence of async/await, but the trade-off (ignored by the article) of the alternative is having to manually deal with synchronization primitives (at least channels), which would make zero sense given that JavaScript is a single-threaded environment.

Rust is a different beast, you can have whichever model you like best (OS threads, M:N threads (with third party libs), async/await) but async/await is by far the most powerful, that's why it's such a big deal that it lands on Rust stable.

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by BatmanAoD on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:38AM (#21483886)
I hadn't heard of "synchronous concurrency", but looking at the Céu paper (only briefly so far), I think the model looks very close to how `async`/`await` works in Rust - possibly even isomorphic. This is really exciting, because Rust's model is unique among mainstream languages (it does not use green threads or fibers, and in fact does not require heap allocation), and I wasn't previously aware of any similar models even among experimental languages.

I'll open a thread on users.rust-lang.com to discuss the similarities/differences with Céu, but for now, here's the main similarity I see:

A Céu "trail" sounds a lot like an `async fn` in Rust. Within these functions, `.await` represents an explicit sync-point, i.e., the function cedes the runtime thread to the concurrency-runtime so that another `async fn` may be scheduled.

(The concurrency-runtime is a combination of two objects, an `Executor` and a `Reactor`, that must meet certain requirements but are not provided by the language or standard library.)

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:10PM (#21485007)
That is a correct understanding of how `await` works in Céu. What is important to note however is that all trails must have bounded execution, which means having an `await` statement. One abstraction that Céu uses is the idea that all reactions to external events are "infinitely" fast - that is, all trails have bounded execution, and computation is so much faster than incoming/outgoing events that it can be considered instantaneous. It's a bit like how one way of looking at garbage collected languages is that they model the computer as having infinite memory.

Having said that, the combination of par/or and par/and constructs for parallel trails of execution, and code/await for reactive objects is like nothing I have ever seen in other languages (it's a little bit actor-modelish, but not quite). I haven't looked closely at Rust though.

Céu also claims to have deterministic concurrency. What it means by that is that when multiple trails await the same external event, they are awakened in lexical order. So for a given sequence of external events in a given order, execution behavior should be deterministic. This kind of determinism seems to be true for all synchronous reactive languages[0]. Is the (single-threaded) concurrency model in Rust comparable here?

The thesis is a bit out of date (only slightly though), the manual for v0.30 or the online playground might be a better start[1][2].

[0] which is like... three languages in total, hahaha. I don't even remember the third one beyond Esterel and Céu. The determinism is quite important though, because Esterel was designed with safety-critical systems in mind.

[1] https://ceu-lang.github.io/ceu/out/manual/v0.30/

[2] http://ceu-lang.org/try.php

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by BatmanAoD on Saturday November 09, 2019 @05:19PM (#21494815)
I'm not sure I see the connection between bounded execution and having an `await` statement. Rust's `async` functions, just like normal functions, definitely aren't total or guaranteed to terminate. They also technically don't need to have an `await` expression; you could write `async fn() -> i32 { 1 + 1 }`. But they do _no_ work until they are first `poll`ed (which is the operation scheduled by the runtime when a function is `await`ed). So I believe that is equivalent to your requirement of "having an `await` statement". You could even think of them as "desugaring" into `async fn() -> i32 { async {}.await; 1 + 1 }` (though of course that's not strictly accurate).

I think it's reasonable to consider well-written `poll` operations as effectively instantaneous in Rust, too, though since I haven't finished the Céu paper yet I don't yet understand why that abstraction is important to the semantics of trails.

As for `par`/`or` and `par`/`and`, I expect these are equivalent to `Future` combinators (which are called things like `.or_else`, `.and_then`, etc).

Since Executors and Reactors are not provided by the language runtime, I believe it would be easy (possibly even trivial) to guarantee the ordering of `Future`-polling for a given event. I am guessing that for Executors that don't provide this feature, the rationale is to support multi-threaded waking (i.e. scheduling `poll` operations on arbitrary threads taken from a thread pool). When using `async`/`await` in a single thread, I'd be mildly surprised if most Executors don't already support some kind of wake-sequencing determinism.

In any case, I've now opened a discussion on users.rust-lang about whether Rust can model synchronous concurrency: https://users.rust-lang.org/t/can-rusts-async-await-model-th...

Re:Async-await on stable Rust by vanderZwan on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:59AM (#21496655)
In Céu, an `await` statement is ceding execution to the scheduler. It is the point at which a trail goes to sleep until being woken up again. So "bounded" here means "is guaranteed to go to sleep again (or terminate) after being woken up". The language does not compile code loops if it cannot guarantee that they terminate or not have an `await` statement in every loop.

I'll try to explain how the "instantaneousness" matters for the sake of modelling determinism. Take the example of reacting to a button press: whenever an external button press event comes in, all trails that are currently awaiting that button press are awakened in lexical order. Now imagine that there are multiple trails in an infinite loop that await a button press, and they all take longer to finish than the speed at which the user mashes a button. In that case the button events are queued up in the order that they arrive. If the user stops then eventually all button presses should get processed, in the correct order.

The idea is that external events get queued up in the order that they arrive, and that the trails react in deterministic fashion to such a sequence events: if the exact same sequence of events arrives faster or slower, the eventual output should be the same. So while I might produce congestion if I mash a button very quickly, it should have the same results as when I press them very slowly.

Now, you may think "but what if you were asked to push a button every two seconds, with a one second time-window? Then the speed at which you press a button does matter!" Correct, but in that case the two second timer and one second time window also count as external events, and when looking at all external events then it again only matters in what the order in which all of these external events arrive at the Céu program.

Lacking further knowledge about Rust I obviously cannot say anything about the rest of your comment, but I hope you're right about the `Future` combinators because I really enjoyed working with Céu's concurrency model.