News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:11AM (#21473304)
There is an approach of modern astrology that is not predictive and mystical, and that appeals to many because it is non-judgemental and makes no scientific claim for itself. It's not a scam or a swindle, it's only claim is being a guide or tool for creativity.

It works in the same way the I Ching does, simply by presenting connections and ideas to people and allowing them to draw conclusions, resolve issues and work on their healing.

Without the I Ching we would not have the best of Philip K Dick, so dismissing all forms of astrology disempowers those for whom it is genuinely useful and inspirational.

This is an unfashionable and unscientific view, but that does not decrease the value for humans who - it turns out - are never 100% rational beings, and that's a wonderful thing.

Re:I was an astrologer by bena on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:36AM (#21473531)
And without amphetamines and his suicide attempt we wouldn't have A Scanner Darkly.

That doesn't make either of those things good.

So I really wouldn't template my life off of things Philip K Dick did.

Re:I was an astrologer by samatman on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:00AM (#21474324)
The suicide attempt is its own thing, but honesty compels me to consider PKD both an argument for and against the goodness of amphetamines.

World War II is a fairly compelling argument agains them, admittedly.

Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:43AM (#21473578)
My point is he used an artform to inspire his art, and we all should be afforded that privilege.

Yes I believe art is a good thing, whether it turns you into a murderer or a saint is a different topic.

Re:I was an astrologer by bena on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:23AM (#21474575)
My point is that Philip K Dick was Philip K Dick. The I Ching didn't make him a brilliant artist. Neither did amphetamines. Neither did attempting suicide. He did all of those things and was a brilliant artist.

Yes, he used aspects of his life to influence his art, but everyone does. Whether they realize it or not.

So even had Philip K Dick not heard of the I Ching, he would have still produced brilliant work.

Re:I was an astrologer by zentropia on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:11AM (#21473844)
It remembers me the idea of magic by Alan Moore. Magic as tools for inspirations, not as supernatural tools.
Re:I was an astrologer by malvosenior on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:21AM (#21473376)
This assumes that there are no negatives to introducing and supporting anti-science en mass. I think society is at a very real risk when it embraces false reasoning and anti-intellectualism. We need more logic and fact based thinking in our world, not less.
Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:41AM (#21473556)
By this logic art is anti-science.

The value of the I Ching or elements of astrology is the value of art.

Re:I was an astrologer by malvosenior on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:43AM (#21473574)
Art doesn't pretend to have the ability to predict the future through mystical means. It doesn't present an illogical premise that's meant to be taken seriously.

You might view astrology as art, which is fine but plenty of people really believe in it.

Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:49AM (#21473633)
To be clear, only some parts of astrology pretend to predict the future through mystical means.

Just as some parts of religion insist their version is the only truth.

So I believe the most reasoned response on these topics will depend on whether we are talking about the whole or a part.

Re:I was an astrologer by otikik on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:37PM (#21476535)
> only some parts of astrology pretend to predict the future through mystical means.

This is the first time I hear this and I am pretty sure if I asked anyone on the street they would feel the same.

Re:I was an astrologer by malvosenior on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:42AM (#21474150)
Isn't mysticism the most important part? I've only ever heard people who believe in astrology reference that aspect of it (opposed to say the aesthetics of the movement).
Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:31PM (#21475882)
For the mainstream modern audience, yes you're probably right.

But astrology has rich and deep history of specialist variations, unsurprising if you spent a moment comparing Aztec, Mayan, Indian, Ancient Greek and several other civilizations who all furthered debate and branched this way and that.

Each of them was merely attempting to understand themselves further, and succeeding in part no thanks to science but to wisdom.

Re:I was an astrologer by bena on Thursday November 07, 2019 @11:26AM (#21474596)
They're engaging in a traditional motte and bailey argument.

Astrology is bullshit mysticism, so you can't defend it on any practical issue. But it is fanciful, so you can kinda suggest that it has some value as fiction.

But Harry Potter is just as fanciful and no one is trying to predict the future by figuring out which House they belong to. Which is just about as useful as astrology.

Re:I was an astrologer by jmkd on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:27PM (#21475836)
Was unaware of motte and bailey so thanks for the heads up.

You can say astrology is bullshit mysticism if you can also say religion is bullshit mysticism.

If you want to say the latter that's fine, but I believe the discussion should be more nuanced (despite being an anti-theist myself).

I'm just trying to find a way to say that astrology is a bigger, broader topic than those merely aware of newspaper horoscopes know about.

As such to discuss it in a single generalist put down is to exhibit ignorance of or disinterest in complexity.

Re:I was an astrologer by bena on Thursday November 07, 2019 @03:20PM (#21476893)
Ok. Religion is bullshit mysticism.

I'm not a big believer in the paranormal