The ability to fork is the point of open source, because it assures continuity. The price of this is the non-zero probability of hostile forks (which I would not classify as 'abuse'). I think there's a section of technologist who license their software for pragmatic (traction, fixing bugs) and not ideological reasons and get surprised when someone forks the project in a way they don't like.
But why not? That seems like such an arbitrary distinction if it weren't for the fact that the company is trying to profit on being the exclusive hosted provider of the software. Why wouldn't I want to pay a company that's better at ops to host sentry for me?
The options are: Use Sentry.io, host it yourself, or use something else.
Did you mean Opbeat? They did use Sentry client code in their service implementation (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12800833) but their focus was on APM not exception management.
If they can do a better job of marketing with that new name, they deserve the success.
Who will win? Who should win?
It would please my personal sense of justice if the big R&D company also won, but I am satisfied with the simpler requirement of end users not getting shafted and the product thriving.
It's no guarantee that a company with 10/2 of marketing/R&D split would be any better than the other company with 2/10 of marketing/R&D.
Anyway, "morals" aren't the standard by which these things are judged in practice, ethics via laws are, and I'm fairly certain most legal systems don't see the practice of IP theft as fine.
There are a lot of different reasons [1] why someone might want to maintain an open source business and the threat of someone forking your business might not outweigh other positive effects.
--
[1] Transparency for privacy/security reasons, political leaning towards free software, hope of third parties tracking down bugs, PR boost within the open source community, etc.
At the same time, I remember seeing a new startup that had completely ripped off Sentry + docs and had just done a find and replace for the company name. I thought I had read about it on HN but I can't find the link. It's clear we need a license that allows software to be developed in the open but prevents this type abuse.
I don't know if this license is the solution. It clearly isn't open source and should not be construed as such (they are very clear about this in the post), but I haven't seen other better proposals either. Armchair criticism is easy, and this seems like a reasonable middle-ground. We'll keep using Sentry and continue to be customers. Outside of their Sentry.io product, they have released and contributed to a ton of other Open Source libraries. As I understand it, that will continue. For me, this passes the sniff test.