Re:There are many small orbital launch vehicles proposed or ...
by DuskStar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:23PM
(#21458843)
But smallsat launchers only make sense if they have a lower cost/kg (unlikely vs the F9) or if they're being used for an orbit/launch time that doesn't have enough demand for a rideshare. And if the space launch market gets big enough to support 100 smallsat launchers, a F9 rideshare into that special orbit will probably have enough takers to make it cheaper than the smallsat launcher would have.
Re:There are many small orbital launch vehicles proposed or ...
by elil17 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @10:44PM
(#21459562)
Smaller diameter rockets have a much worse fuel ratio (because of fuel tank geometry issues), so there’s no way they’ll ever be cheaper than larger rockets. They fundamentally must use more fuel per kg of payload than large rockets because fuel tank wet mass to dry mass ratio increases linearly with diameter.
Re:There are many small orbital launch vehicles proposed or ...
by DuskStar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @10:57PM
(#21459611)
Right, and that's why smallsat launchers are only really viable for orbits/launches that can't be served by rideshares. Better to pay $5mil for an Electron to launch your smallsat than to book an entire Falcon 9, even if the $/kg is far higher.
Re:There are many small orbital launch vehicles proposed or ...
by greglindahl on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:16PM
(#21459662)
Companies like Momentus [1] are happy to sell you a tug that will turn a rideshare to a common orbit into your unusual orbit.
SpaceX's rate for an Electron-sized payload is 1/6 the price of an Electron.
Re:There are many small orbital launch vehicles proposed or ...
by DuskStar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:48PM
(#21459794)
I have to say, 5 km/s delta v is more than I was expecting from a tug like that. Still, I really wouldn't be surprised if adding one of those to your smallsat would cost more than $5m.
While I agree with your general point, do we completely understand the opportunity that space launch/travel/exploration provides yet?
The opportunity may be exponentially bigger than we currently understand.