News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An act regarding the use of offensive words by Lio on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:55PM (#21455422)
I find American English weirdly puritanical in some respects.

For instance this use of <letter>-word as a signifier for a thing you find so offensive you can't say out loud or even write down in a discussion even though in this discussion we're not actually applying it to a person or hypothetical person.

(I've not used it here as I think I can make this point without using it or hopefully causing offence).

We have to careful of branding words themselves "hate speech" without reference to context.

The particular word I think you refer to is perfectly legitimate when used in the context of the animal it describes.

In fact as I understand it's not so much offensive because it compares a person to an animal as it is because it's also a slang name for the world's oldest profession and implies ownership and coercion with regard to that profession (both of which I'd say were dehumanising in a different and more offensive way).

Banning the use of an everyday word in all contexts comes across not as about hate speech but as a way of an in group asserting control on others.

I feel the same about the C-word. In my culture, whilst still a bit blue for everyday use, it's much less offensive than in yours. We apply it in all sorts of situations that are not dehumanising.

There are no comments on this comment yet.