Re:In the 17th Century, Leibniz Dreamed of a Machine That Co...
by mbrock on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:48AM
(#21451234)
It is amusing to imagine the neural network mind growing advanced enough to realize that to help it level up in clarity of thought and communication, it needs to develop a system of automatic symbolic logic...
Re:In the 17th Century, Leibniz Dreamed of a Machine That Co...
by goldenkey on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:23AM
(#21451714)
There are binary/discrete neural networks. :-)
Re:In the 17th Century, Leibniz Dreamed of a Machine That Co...
by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:53AM
(#21461082)
Well, the original artificial neuron by Pitts and McCulloch was a propositional logic circuit- but that strain of research, too, has fallen by the wayside in favour of neural nets that can be trained with backpropagation of error.
Re:In the 17th Century, Leibniz Dreamed of a Machine That Co...
by goldenkey on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:02AM
(#21461121)
One can train binary NN via backprop by using qbits. Samples are taken, and backprop can be done as if the result was X% 1 and (1-X)% 0. It can be noisy and slow but it is a way to do it.
Leibniz's ideas on the other hand, of combining symbols to generate and evaluate human language, that's the spirit that permeates Good, Old-Fashioned AI, symbolic, and logic-based artificial intelligence. Today, most NLP researchers would say that the logic-based branch of research, common as it was until very recently, was after all a dead end that did not lead anywhere. It would be interesting to be able to know what Leibniz would have made of that.
Perhaps one day (in the far distant future, when my bones are dust and my memories lost) we'll be able to reproduce the great philosopher's thoughts from his writings and reconstruct his personality, in part or in whole. And then we could pose to him the question: "Master, what do you think of the machine that now houses your intellect"?