News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by nullc on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:53PM (#21444251)
With the exception of talos and various bits of used hardware POWER has only been available in rather expensive systems-- so no onramp.

Even with things this announced it remains the case that EPYC, not power9, is the king of memory bandwidth per dollar at least at most price-points.

Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by rbanffy on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:25PM (#21444645)
> at most price-points

Worth noting POWER9 reaches price points (and profit margins) EPYC server vendors can only dream of.

Sadly, you are right about onboarding. I'd love to have a POWER9 box as my desktop workstation, but I simply can't justify the price compared to a beefy Xeon (or EPYC) box. IBM would be wise to have a POWER9 that could compete with low-end Xeon servers.

Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by nullc on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:45PM (#21444912)
Indeed, there is a realm of astronomical hardware that is covered by power9 that you're not finding amd hardware for, but going down to "merely the price of a new car" and below is where the comparison falls apart.

And the astronomical end really only matters if you need special requirements like single system images... if you just need lots of cycles or memory bandwidth, a cluster of lower end hosts (and 40GBE nics) is a lot less pricey.

> a POWER9 that could compete with low-end Xeon servers.

The Talos II is in the vague order of magnitude for that... which is A LOT better than before it existed.

Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by rbanffy on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:59PM (#21445070)
True, but it's still, sadly, above my impulse-buy limit.

To make things a bit harder, I live in Europe and there aren't as many sources of used POWER8+ gear as there are in North America.

Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by skykooler on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#21444733)
That's in recent years, of course. Previously, POWER was the architecture for Apple computers, as well as the Sony PlayStation 3.
Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by nullc on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:35PM (#21444795)
I had a PS3 for building for power/cell... until sony bricked the darn thing! :)

After that for a while my PPC test box was a dual g4 xserve but it stopped booting inexplicably.

I have talos now and am pretty happy with it, but even that still struggles to compete with epyc in terms of price/performance (though at least a comparison can be made there).

Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by rbanffy on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:00PM (#21445094)
I have some memories of the Cell processor, none of them fond. That beast was the hardest thing to program I ever saw. It made the first generation Xeon Phi's look like a dream.
Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by nullc on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:46PM (#21448040)
I think it just depended on what you were doing on it, I 'ported' the CELT (Opus predecessor) to it in like.. an afternoon.
Re:IBM Adds POWER9 AIO, Pushes for an Open Memory-Agnostic I... by snagglegaggle on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:54PM (#21446401)
If you really want what POWER has to offer, like the ability to explore low level board firmware, the price is extremely competitive.