If I have a structure S with an associative operation, and another structure G with an associative operation and a neutral element, I will say that S and G are different algebras, not "different magmas". Others looking at S or G will not ask "oh, what kind of magma do you have there", they will ask what kind of algebra.
So... Yes, these are both (special cases of) magmas, but the general term used for them is "algebra" or "algebraic structure". Don't you agree?
So you're saying people shorten the phrase "algebraic structure" to "algebra"; this hasn't been my experience.
Of course I added extra structure since I wanted to make a point about different kinds of algebraic structures which are all subsumed by the term "algebraic structure" or "algebra". And it's only possible to distinguish kinds of algebraic structures by differences in structure.
But adding extra structure in one example doesn't mean that I somehow exclude magmas from the definition. Here is the example again, extended to be include a component with no extra structure:
If I have a structure M with no structure but an operation, a structure S with an associative operation, and another structure G with an associative operation and a neutral element, I will say that M and S and G are different algebras, not "different magmas". Others looking at M or S or G will not ask "oh, what kind of magma do you have there", they will ask what kind of algebra.
Of course this extension by M doesn't change anything about the validity of the example. Magmas are just as included in the term "algebraic structure" as semigroups, groups, rings, and fields are.
> So you're saying people shorten the phrase "algebraic structure" to "algebra"; this hasn't been my experience.
<shrug> It has been mine. Wikipedia has lots of uses of the phrase "the algebra of": https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=%22the+algebra+o..., always meaning something like "the algebraic structure of set X with operations f, g, and h".
Algebraic stucture, sure, but _algebra_, absolutely not.
An algebra is a module with a compatible multiplication which has an identity element. If I had a magma and you asked about my "algebra" I would be very confused about where you were seeing all the extra structure.
As someone else pointed out elsethread, the term seems to be overloaded in different branches of mathematics.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_algebra: "Universal algebra (sometimes called general algebra) is the field of mathematics that studies algebraic structures themselves, not examples ("models") of algebraic structures. [...] In universal algebra, an algebra (or algebraic structure) is a set A together with a collection of operations on A."
I think this comes from competing definitions of the term 'algebra'. There's what, for want of anything better than the terrible term, I'll call the 'algebraist's algebra', which is (at least) a ring that is compatibly a module over some other ring; and there's what, as smadge (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21443587) mentions, could be called the 'universal algebraist's algebra', which is a model for a certain signature, of which the algebraist's algebra is just one special case. EDIT: I see that matt_noonan (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21443892) made this point several hours ago, but I leave this post in case the links below are convincing.
For sources maybe more authoritative than Wikipedia, you might consult Springer's Encyclopedia of Mathematics (https://www.encyclopediaofmath.org/index.php/Variety_of_univ...) or the nLab (https://ncatlab.org/nlab/show/universal+algebra).
But that is different from an algebraic structure. An algebraic structure is just some set with some operations and laws. It can be magmas, monoids, groups etc.
And abstract algebra is also a necessary term to differentiate from "ordinary" algebra that is taught in middle schools and high schools, where algebra only means using letters to substitute numbers.
It's unfortunate.
Most of the structures called algebras (e.g. boolean algebras) have at least two operations and these operations frequently interact via distributivity or something like that. Other examples are ring-like, like a sigma algebra in measure theory.
I've never really encountered anyone saying "algebra" for a generic algebraic structure. I think with this definition Cohn was trying to start a trend that didn't catch on.
Which one(s) you have been exposed to just depends on which mathematical subcultures you’ve interacted with.
Mathematics Wikipedia is sometimes very biased towards certain points of view (usually more undergraddy, as evidenced by its insistence with the "abstract algebra" term), so I think it's being a bit too pushy with its "algebra" definition here. I've edited the term to say that this usage of "algebra" is a universal algebra thing.
Does this really happen? Do people really say generic "algebra" for any set with operations?
(And as an aside, I don't like the "abstract algebra" monicker. It sounds so immature and undergraddy. There isn't an ordinary algebra and an abstract algebra. It's all just algebra.)